Writing Sample 5
The following is an excerpt from an article I had written about masculinities in male cop
movies in South India. Since it is just an excerpt I have given the list of movies at the end of
the piece.
MASCULINITIES IN MALE COP MOVIES
In the male cop movies that were reviewed there is variety of masculinities that are
constructed and portrayed. I classify the cops into 3 categories:
•
•
•
The action/shooting star cop, who mindlessly swings into action, uses violence
excessively and is very destructive like Prabhakaran, Rathnavel Pandian, Ramarajyam
and Vikram Rathore. They do very little thinking like Prabhakaran who gets an entire
village killed at the hands of Veerabhadran due to his methods and insufficient
planning.
The thinking cop is the one who thinks a lot, takes down notes, analyses them all the
time and enjoys playing mind games. They are even emasculated at times and to make
up for that they fight or enter the action mode when the situation demands. They are
the intelligent cops like Chadrashekhar (who keeps playing chess throughout the
movie), J.K (who finds a breakthrough in the case) and Sethurama Iyer.
The balancer cop is the one who is a good mixture of the intelligent/thinking type as
well as a shooting star type. They are street smart, dexterous, racy and aggressive. The
rest that is Anbuchelvan , Duraisingam, Aaruchaami, Raghavan and the second half of
Rathnavel Pandian and Vikram Rathore when the petty thieves are impersonating
them.
The point that I wish to make through this sort of categorisation is that even though these
cops have different methods of approaching crime and cases, inherently they are all good
cops only (even if some of their methods would involve making short term friendships with
‘evil’ like in Saamy where Aaruchaami initially becomes friends with the villain, kingmaker
Perumal Pichai only in order to destroy him later). The masculine in these movies is both
dangerous and good.
Firstly, I would like to discuss about the normative masculinity that is portrayed in the films
reviewed. It is essential for Tamil, Malayali and Telugu men to sport a moustache especially
when they are in tough roles such as police officers, army men, goon, politician or any other
role where physical and intellectual prowess are both required. So, the moustache becomes
the defining characteristic and necessity of these tough cops to be treated as normative men
and defines their masculinity. In other films where the police man does not sport a
moustache, he is either a bad cop like Ajith in Mankatha (2012) even if he is the lead
character or he is not a Tamil man. There are handpicked movies that have a powerful, honest
male lead as a police officer without a moustache like Osthi (2012) and such movies
generally do not fare very well especially with the audiences other than the multiplex
audiences. The moustache is also a symbol of their virility, transition into adulthood (from
boyhood) and bravery/daredevilry. It is not uncommon to hear people say, “how is this baby
face going to take on a huge villain, baby face does not even have a moustache”. So, most
directors make sure that the hero in their movie has a moustache and a particular kind of
moustache while signing them in. Apart from the moustache, the normative masculinity of
these cops entails being a Hindu, upper caste man, mostly middle class, compulsorily
heterosexual and able-bodied. It is also noteworthy that it is only actors who have achieved
the status of a star are the ones who are cast in the role of a male cop; newcomers are
generally not considered for the role. So, age is also an important factor in the attainment of
hegemony. The names of most of the cops in these movies are also interesting in that they are
given different deities’ names or the name has something to do with lord like Aaaruchaami
(chaamy-saamy meaning God), Duraisingam (where Durai means lord and Singam means
lion, the king of the forest), Rathnavel (the name of the Tamil deity Muruga), Ramarajyam,
etc.
The most powerful characters in these films would be the cop and the main villain both of
whom will be hegemonic in a sense but finally, the cop will the most powerful symbol of the
plot when he destroys the evil in the form of the villain. The portrayal of the villain borrows
from the regional legends of demons, rakshasa, picasus, etc. who are mostly dark skinned,
malevolent and vengeful, may or may not be from the lower class/caste but definitely have
power and money. The villains are also shown as having indomitable desire for sex, body,
money, power and fame. For example, Mayilvahanam, the villain character of Singam is
shown as being a real estate mafia who kidnaps people for money. Perumal Pichai of Saamy
is again shown as a land mafia, running several wine shops in the city and an electoral
kingmaker. Veerabhadran of Captain Prabhakaran is lustful as far as women are concerned
and is also a sandalwood smuggler. In Oru CBI Diary Kurippu, the actual killer of Omana,
kills her in a fit of the moment when she did not oblige to his sexual advances. In order to
show their power and prowess, there are elaborate stunt sequences where they singlehandedly take on the villain/goons/other ‘evil’ characters in order to restore the rule of
law/save lives/save people. The sense of authority comes also because of their
institutionalised power which comes which is given to them as police officers by the state and
the law unlike the villains in these movies whose power and authority comes from money,
political power, criminality (which causes fear among people) and man power in the form of
many beefed up sidekicks. The cop’s power is also portrayed through the numerous instances
where he is not only saving women but also other men who are emasculated like a helpless
father/brother. There are also a bunch of wingmen that the cop has around whom he not only
throws around authority but also love. The underlying idea behind these movies is that good
always triumphs over the evil and whenever evil runs loose, there would be timely
intervention by the star hero acting as the cop through a ‘subsequent performance of
aggressive, violent machismo effectively which averts crisis’ (Muraleedharan 2005: 78) or
restores good. So, in a sense, the star hero is deified. This deification is portrayed through a
series of low angle shots called the ‘Darsanic view’ by Ravi Vasudevan (Vasudevan: 5)
which makes the audience look up to the authority of the hero rather than a straight shot
where the beholder (the audience) has the power and reduces the hero to an object on screen.
The low angle shots show the muscularity, virility and power of the hero. This technique is
also used in the posters of cop movies. In Yudham Sei though, the darsanic view is not given
to the hero for reasons- one, is that Cheran is not an established actor who has claimed the
star status; he is a director who recently turned actor and has been playing emasculated roles
like in this movie (though in this movie he does have his moments of asserting his
masculinity as a cop) and the second reason is that the darsanic view is reserved for the
killers in the movie who are affected by the group of evil characters in the movie which
organise peep shows for lustful old men by kidnapping girls, drugging them and raping them.
The family is killing all those involved in this and are in a ‘punitha por’ (holy war). The
darsanic shots are to show the holiness of their deeds even though it involves violent killing.
THE MOVIES THAT WERE REVIEWED
•
Tamil movies-
o
•
•
Captain Prabhakaran (1991) with Vijayakanth in the lead as Prabhakaran, an IFS officer on a mission to save
an IFS officer held captive by Veerabhadran (modelled on the lines of Veerappan) and also to capture
Veerabhadran.
o Saamy (2003) with Vikram in the lead as Aaruchaamy, a newly posted DCP to Tirunelveli City in order to
restore the deteriorating law and order situation in the city.
o Kaakha Kaakha (2003) with Suriya in the lead as Anbuchelvan IPS, a special cell officer posted to reduce
crime in the city of Chennai.
o Vettaiyadu Vilayadu (2006) with Kamalahasan in the lead as DCP Raghavan trying to solves a case of serial
killing in India and USA.
o Singam (2010) with Suriya in the lead as Inspector Duraisingam, an honest cop who gets transferred to
Chennai from his village due to his daredevilry against a powerful dada, Mayilvahanam and ends up
cleansing the city of the deeds of the goon.
o Yudham Sei (2011) with Cheran in the lead as J.K, a CB-CID officer who is trying to solve the case of a
spree of suspicious murders alongside trying to find his lost sister.
o Siruthai (2011) with Karthi in the lead playing a double role as Rathnavel Pandian IPS and a petty thief,
Rocket Raja. Rathnavel Pandian is an honest upright who faces with a near-death situation while trying to
fight a gang of criminals in Devipattnam and is in his death bed when his look alike is found by his colleagues
to replace him and finish the gang of criminals and free the people of Devipattnam.
3 Malayalam movieso Oru CBI Diary Kurippu (1988) with Mammootty in the lead as Sethurama Iyer, a CBI officer solving the
murder case of Omana which was closed off as a suicide by the local police but was reopened on court order
due to a petition by her family which suspects she was killed.
o Sethurama Iyer IPS (2004) with Mammootty in the lead as Sethurama Iyer, CBI officer. It is the third sequel
to Oru CBI Diary Kurippu. In this movie, Isow Alex is convicted of 7 cold-blooded murders and is given a
life sentence. But he says that he had murdered only 6 of the 7 and Sethurama Iyer tries to find out who killed
the 7th person, Manikkunju.
o Grandmaster (2012) with Mohanlal in the lead as Chandrashekhar IPS, Chief of the Metro Crime Division
(MCD), who is an ardent player of chess and is dragged into solving a serial killing of women in the
alphabetical order by the killer himself who says he is an admirer of the officer and hence, would like to play
this mind game with him.
2 Telugu movies
o Rowdy Inspector (1992) with Balakrishna in the lead as Inspector Ramarajyam who single handedly fights
crime in the town and wants to restore the rule of law. In this endeavour he is helped by Auto Rani
(Vijayashanthi) who also plays his love interest.
o Vikramarkudu (2006) with Ravi Teja in the lead as ASP Vikram Rathore, an honest police officer and Athili
Sathi Babu, a petty thief. Siruthai is a remake of this movie which was also remade in Hindi as Rowdy
Rathore in 2012.