Case Study Sample 2
The Dreamer: Arul Kumar
Arul Kumar, hazel-eyed little boy studying class III, can be deceptive in the classroom with his reserved and shy
demeanour. He is a different person outside the classroom- extremely talkative and enthusiastic capable of
giving vivid descriptions about his colourful world and the things he yearns for. He knows how to fully utilise
limited resources, be it using an old broken cupboard as a ship to play with or imagining his cycle as a racing
bike. He is indeed a dreamer. Among the many things that Arul wants to be when he grows up like Police
Officer, Army Officer, etc., most importantly, he wants to be rich. Being rich, he believes, will let him fly planes
and sail on real ships. Arul’s favourite subject is English since he feels that knowing English would help him go
abroad. Arul is one of the tidiest children in his class and won the Project’s ‘Tidy Star of the month’ title from his
class.
Family Background
Arul’s family hails from a small village in Virudhunagar district in the South of Tamil Nadu and came to Chennai
for better livelihood opportunities. His father is a security guard at a College and feels very guilty for not having
taken his education seriously due to which he feels he is still struggling in life while his younger brother, an STO
in the PWD, is well settled. He repeatedly keeps telling his children that they should not take studies lightly like
he did in order to have a comfortable life. Arul has two mothers, both of whom work as helpers in the Hostel
Mess. He has a younger brother, Thiruselvam, also in class I. The family lives in a spacious quarters within the
college campus. The parents do not get sufficient time for the children, and are so busy that they do not get the
time to even bring order in the house. The children say that the parents do not fight very often, that their father
drinks only once in a while, and that otherwise their home is peaceful.
Erstwhile Arul
Arul joined Lady Nye School in class II, before which studied class I in the Government school at his village.
When he first joined this school, the HM (who is also his class teacher) felt that this boy may not have done
even his class I and has directly joined class II since he knew next to nothing. He could not write his name
clearly then. Upon going through his mark sheets and notebooks from class II, it was observed that Arul
definitely was worse off when he joined. His handwriting was poor, his level of understanding of subjects and
instructions was low, and he merely managed to answer 2-3 questions in exams and tests. He also had a
problem of mirror writing. But the HM vouches for the fact that this boy was never naughty or unruly in class,
that he has always been very obedient and disciplined. He would complete his homework and do his other
work on time. His answer sheets and notebooks do point to the fact that this boy did show improvement from
class II to class III. Though the improvement was only negligible, it was still an improvement.
Engaging with Arul
The observation of the para-teacher and us is that Arul used be very reserved, withdrawn and scared. The parateacher recalled that the boy used to seem depressed, uninterested, very frightened of taking initiatives, and
would keep thinking about the consequences of him giving wrong answers. He would sit in the last row and his
attention would be wavering. It was also observed that Arul would interact with only one other boy in his class
and did not have any other friends. His parents too said that he seemed very quiet and withdrawn at home for a
few years, right in contrast to his erstwhile talkative personality. We believe one main reason for this could be
that his parents often tend to compare him with his younger brother who fares better academically.
The para-teacher too had similar observations about Arul Kumar as his class teacher. He was identified as a
slow learner by the HM and the para-teacher at the beginning of the project in October. The para-teacher said
that when she first started working with him, he did not know the English or Tamil Alphabet properly. He was
relatively better off in Maths. His handwriting was also not too good she observed. In the Student Assessment of
slow learners done in December 2014, Arul fared much better than most slow learners of his school in the basic
understanding tests. He was in the average range in memory test while he was in the needs improvement
category in the concentration/attention test and in writing. His reading skills were in the poor category.
Working with Arul and his Progress
The para-teacher and the Project had to focus on resolving issues such as fear, low self-esteem, lower academic
attention/concentration, lack of interest, improper academic foundation, etc. in order improve his academic
outcomes. We also had to address latent issues like lack of sufficient appreciation from parents, feeling of
loneliness, constant comparison with younger brother, etc. for his betterment. In order to bring Arul out of his
shell and improve his self-esteem, the para-teacher has been paying personal attention to him. She kept
interacting with him and encouraging him to participate more in class and in tuitions. Even now if he is found
quiet in class, the para-teacher motivates him and his spirits and energy pick up instantly, she observes. We
have also spoken to the parents about keeping Arul motivated and giving him a little more attention. The
parents too have observed now that Arul speaks more freely to them and his fears are slow fading away.
Changes seen in Arul
He started responding positively to the activity-based approach adopted by the Project. Initially he started
showing interest in the activities but did not still show the same interest in studies. The memory game and the
puzzles used to be his favourite activities then. He would therefore, take interest in these while he would
hesitate to do English and vocabulary based ones. He slowly started learning the Alphabet (English and Tamil)
well and started reading. Now, Arul has started shown both initiative and interest in activities as well as
studies. This has been observed by his parents, the class teacher (HM), the para-teacher and us. He sits in the
front row in class and participates in all activities during tuitions. He has picked up speed in memory game and
puzzles pointing to an improvement in concentration and attention. He now, knows the English and Tamil
Alphabet well. He can read and write 3-letter words. He comes forward to do vocabulary based games like
jumbled words, word building, etc. His reading has improved immensely. The HM is very happy with this
improvement in Arul. As far as exams are concerned, he has shown the best improvement in Maths as
compared to earlier; his grade in the half yearly exam went up to A from B.
This hazel-eyed boy has come quite a long way academically but he still has a long way to go before he can
completely come in line with the rest of the class. It is hoped that Arul continues to respond well to the Project
initiatives and ceases to be a slow learner soon.