Fiction Proofread/Editing Sample
CHAPTER 1
The soft sway of the water stilled as the Fates looked on. “Are we certain this is the
only way?” The shortest of the Fates asked the question but only because she questioned
Deleted: . A
everything, already knowing the answer.
“It unfolds as it should,” a slender cloaked figure replied.
“Thus far. Each must be tested and do his or her part. Even the son of Ares. No one
avoids their fate,” the one standing on the far right of the pool added calmly.
“But he has always been aware,” a raspy voice countered.
“Yet, for the most part, he’s lived human lives. This will require the first use of all of
his powers and once they taste it, they will only want more,” the shortest stated.
Deleted: , n
Commented [SF1]: Although not a proofreading
comment, I do want to make a note that in this speak, the
first sentence is grammatically correct with “His or her
part. In this portion, it goes to “their”. I’d change it to this:
“Even the son of Ares. No one can avoid destiny.” That
way you avoid the pronoun antecedent issue and say
essentially the same thing.
The others nodded in agreement.
“Sooner or later, they will all be tested,” the one on the right said.
“Failure is true death,” the slender figure replied.
“For us all.”
****
Ledo opened his eyes to stare into the blaze of the sun. Immediately, he closed them.
Deleted: , t
The movement caused pain to bang behind his shut lids and into his skull until it echoed
Deleted: ,
throughout his body. Unsure why he could see the sun, or where he was for that matter, he
Deleted: . H
moaned. Where the fuck was he? What happened? The last thing he remembered was
tranzing and chasing after Ze’s lightning bolt. He caught it in his talons, adding his own
powers to guide it where it needed to go: right into the entrance of Tartarus in an attempt
Commented [SF2]: I’m assuming spelling of this word is
okay.
Deleted: . R
to destroy it. He remembered the explosion and an endless sensation of his atoms being
ripped apart as he was wrenched from his vulture form. After that, it’d all been a blur.
Deleted: ,
An icy wind blew across his naked body. He shivered and tried to sit up. His human
Deleted: ice
ass was freezing. It was so fucking cold. How long had he been out? The temperature
Deleted: , h
shouldn’t affect him like this. Where was he? He glanced around and realized he lay in the
middle of a white sea of ice and blowing snow as far as his eyes could see. Was this the
North Pole? Is this where the entrance had been hidden, deep beneath the ice?
That made sense, but no, not the North. The magnetic energy felt more like the South.
Antarctica. That was where he was. Actually, what he was…was fucked. While he could
change his form, he couldn’t create clothes, and when he changed, his clothes were
destroyed. Usually, he was able to make it back home or to someplace where he’d stashed
clothes. Not this time. Sometimes, it really sucked being the son of a god. He shivered.
Normally, the cold wouldn’t bother him, but this was a bitter cold and he’d exerted a lot of
energy. He also feared he might have lost quite a bit of time.
His bird form wouldn’t help him here. He needed something that would function better
in this stark environment. The other form he inherited from dear Dad, one that was part
dog, part wolf. With a thought, his body shimmered, his bones seeming to liquefy before
contorting. Changing in less than a nanosecond, he went from man to a dark gray and
brown cross between a wolf and a dog with a white patch on his head. He raised his nose
Commented [SF3]: One of these commas an em‐dash
instead?
Deleted: , t
Commented [SF4]: Tenses need to remain consistent.
“That’s” is present tense; this narrative is past tense.
Deleted: ’
Commented [SF5]: Not a proofread, but I’d consider
changing this part to, “and he destroyed his clothes when
he changed.” That way, the sentence remains active and
Ledo remains the subject. It’ll also eliminate some
commas.
Deleted:
Deleted: , n
Deleted: , n
Deleted: , h
Commented [SF6]: Global note: Two independent
clauses not joined by a conjunction must be punctuated
either with a period or a semicolon, not a comma.
Deleted: dad
Deleted: that’s
and scented the air. In this form, his senses were heightened tenfold. There. He caught a
Deleted:
whiff of humans. One, scent in particular, tantalized his senses. Humans meant warmth,
Deleted: ,
fire. Food. He took off at a dead run following his nose.
Ledo was larger than most dogs or wolves, stronger and faster. Still, by the time he
arrived at his destination, the sun was just getting ready for bed. He circled the place. It
was the equivalent of a double-wide mobile home, three of them in the boxed shape of an
L. With his enhanced hearing, he listened in on the conversation. Some sort of scientific
expedition instead of an adventure-for-shits-and-giggles group. Figures they were studying
the weather phenomena and magnetic anomalies, trying to figure out what had been
Deleted: , s
Commented [SF7]: Not proofreading, however, I think
there’s a number discrepancy here, or there needs to be
clarity regarding what the antecedent to “them” is. If it’s
the equivalent of a doublewide, what are the three
“thems”? Since I think the “them” refers to the mobile
home, I would suggest to say, “He circled the place, which
was three mobile homes connected in an L‐shape.” or
something similar.
Commented [SF8]: Hyphens because this entire phrase
is modifying “group”.
Commented [SF9]: I would make the noun/pronoun... [1]
happening all over the world for the last month. The hole in the ozone layer was already
Deleted: ,
three times the size of the US and getting larger.
Deleted:
The good news was what he and Ze had done should put a stop to it. But he didn’t kid
himself. It was simply a stopgap measure they’d accomplished. They’d merely stunned
Cronus. Hopefully, it would be long enough for Ze to gather some of the descendants of
Deleted:
Deleted:
Deleted:
Deleted: ,
the Olympians to put a permanent hurt to Cronus once and for all. Meanwhile, he needed
Deleted: ,
to get to a main town and try to contact Ze. This was one time he wished he and Ze were
Deleted: , i
connected, or that his telepathic skills were stronger. Instinct had led him to find Zeus in
Formatted: Do not check spelling or grammar
Commented [SF10]: Another note: This is the first time
... [2]
the first place. Perhaps, instinct would lead Ze to him. He would keep focusing on the once
Commented [SF11]: Former?
god and maybe that would be enough.
Deleted: , p
First things first, Ledo needed food and warmth. Even in his enhanced body, his balls
Deleted: , e
were freezing. He was surprised not to see any dog sleds at the station, but there were a
Deleted: they
helicopter and a couple of snowmobiles in a covered shed. It also looked like the group had
Deleted: did have
triangular slanted umbrella over it, probably making it easier for the snow to slide off to
Commented [SF12]: The antecedent for “they” is too far
up in the next to make this effective, so I changed this.
Also, I put “group” back so there wouldn’t be a pronoun
antecedent issue with another dangling “they”.
one side and protect the transmitter up there. Good, maybe he could use whatever kind of
Deleted: and i
communications device present to send out a call to Ze.
Deleted: they
a generator attached to the mobile station. The top of the station had what looked like a
He decided the best approach was usually the direct one. He didn’t think this group
would buy the idea of a naked man in the middle of the Antarctic in minus 55 Celsius
Deleted: they had
Deleted: , h
Deleted: they
weather, but a dog was another matter. He moved to the side of the helicopter, threw back
his head, and howled so the wind would carry it toward the structure. And he hoped no one
came out with a shotgun to try to plug his sorry ass.
****
Aria sat in her room and took out her journal. Since power was at a premium here,
she’d brought several paper journals with her to keep a personal log of her adventure. She
always did. And so far, it had been an adventure. She read over what she’d written from
the time she’d been added as part of the research team.
As a new PhD candidate, the competition to be part of the six-person team with one of
the foremost physicists of their time was…well, the odds were not good. But she had a
Deleted: , s
Commented [SF13]: She always did what? Bring
journals or keep a personal log?
Deleted: And so far
Deleted: PHD
Deleted:
slight advantage—one of her favorite professors at the University of Chicago was the team
Commented [SF14]: Generally, all‐caps should be
reserved for signs or to indicate strident shouts. Italics
for everything else in text.
leader’s sister. So she’d known about the expedition before it had been made public and
Deleted: NOT
had been one of the first to express interest. It also helped she’d already switched her
Formatted: Font: Italic
research and was studying why the rules of physics had suddenly turned upside down the
last few months.
It wasn’t just the weird weather and expansion of the hole in the ozone layer; the
Deleted: ,
Deleted: was
Deleted: been
Deleted:
magnetism of the poles had been changing, too. Abnormal energy waves were emitting
Deleted: ,
from the South Pole, having a direct adverse effect on the weather. It should have been
Deleted: ,
Deleted: abnormal
twilight here now for a few weeks before changing to night, but there hadn’t been sunlight
Deleted: they’d
here for months. Yet suddenly, there would be stretches of sunlight, then twilight again.
Deleted: had
The strange thing was, it was linked to these weird energy emissions; but as strong as the
emissions were, they couldn’t find the source, the heart of it. But they were close. It lay
somewhere under the vast expanse of ice.
She made the day’s entry in her journal and looked back over her others, pausing on
Commented [SF15]: The subject needed to be
consistent throughout. The sentence staring “It should
have been” indicates there is no specific subject, so
switching to “they” gives one when that’s not the
established focus.
Deleted: , then
Deleted: they’d have
the one made two months ago. In a few minutes, she’d put in a scheduled call to Michael.
Deleted: it
He’d asked her to marry him and stay before she’d left. She hadn’t said no, she couldn’t
Deleted: , i
marry him; she’d wanted to and he must have known that. His clue should have been the
fact they hadn’t had sex in months and they didn’t live together. More her doing than his.
Commented [SF16]: Not proofreading: I would re‐
introduce Aria’s name here since it’s been a while for the
reader.
He asked her not to answer him then, just think about it.
Commented [SF17]: Not proofreading, but this needs
... [3]
He’d been angry she’d accepted the chance to be part of groundbreaking science. He
was a scientist himself and had applied to be part of the expedition. It would have been
Deleted: ,
Deleted:
Deleted:
unheard given their personal relationship, everyone in the department knew they’d been
Commented [SF18]: I’m not sure what’s trying to be... [4]
dating, for them both to have been on the same team. Most relationships didn’t survive
Deleted: don’t
these types of expeditions. At least not the ones she knew about. But she’d made it; he
Deleted: on
hadn’t. She got the feeling part of the reason he’d asked her to marry him was to stop her
from going.
After four years of dating, he’d never once talked about them getting married. In fact,
Deleted: ,
Deleted: didn’t
Commented [SF19]: Unnecessary.
Deleted: ,
he thought marriage was archaic. That all they needed was an understanding. She’d agreed
Commented [SF20]: Tense agreement.
until she hadn’t, realizing she wanted something more. Her own parents had divorced when
Deleted: didn’t
she was young. She spent summers and holidays with both of them, but each had remarried
and their spouses had kids. Suddenly, she went from being an only child to a stepchild with
Deleted: . R
Deleted: , s
Commented [SF21]: This isn’t proofreading, but just... [5]
siblings. Her only constant had been her grandmother before she’d died. Was it any wonder
Commented [SF22]: Not proofreading; but which ... [6]
Aria buried herself in books? Science could never hurt her. Science was based on fact,
Deleted:
things that could be proven. Numbers never lied, never disappointed.
Deleted: Is
Yet, it had no longer felt like enough. She wasn’t sure when that had happened, but it
had. Maybe because she was twenty-five and spent way too much time with her mentor,
Commented [SF23]: Too many “she’s” without
... [7]
Commented [SF24]: Books can be on any subject; I’d
... [8]
Deleted: she
Susan, and saw firsthand what a real committed relationship was like. She and her husband
Deleted: can
had no kids, but they’d been married for thirty years and had sort of adopted Aria.
Commented [SF25]: “It” as in “science”?
Deleted: did
Deleted: had
Page 3: [1] Commented [SF9]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 8:49:00 AM
I would make the noun/pronoun explicit and say, “Ledo figured they were…” because otherwise you have a
shift in tense issue, since “Figures” is present tense and the narrative is past tense.
Page 3: [2] Commented [SF10]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 8:54:00 AM
Another note: This is the first time you use Ze’s full name. This should go the first time you mention Ze,
because you cannot assume readers know who this is even if it’s part of a series.
Page 5: [3] Commented [SF17]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 9:24:00 AM
Not proofreading, but this needs clarity. I think you mean she wanted to say no, but the way this read is
ambiguous. This could mean she wanted to marry him and couldn’t yet, or she’d wanted to say no and
couldn’t yet. I’d just say, “she’d wanted to refuse” to add that clarity, thus eliminating the need for the reader
to go further and clear up that ambiguity.
Page 5: [4] Commented [SF18]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 9:30:00 AM
I’m not sure what’s trying to be said here. Is it, “It wouldn’t have been unheard of” or “it would’ve been
unheard of”? Also, there is an independent clause splitting up another sentence. It’s confusing. I think what’s
trying to be said is this. “It wouldn’t have been unheard of for both of them to have been on the same team.
Everyone in the department knew they were dating.” (Not “they’d been dating”; this implies there’s been a
change in relationship status, and the revelation above doesn’t say they are no longer together despite Aria’s
misgivings.)
Page 5: [5] Commented [SF21]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 9:40:00 AM
This isn’t proofreading, but just because her parents remarried, doesn’t mean she still couldn’t have been an
only stepchild; she’d be her parents’ spouses’ stepchild. This addition clarifies she now has siblings via her
stepparents.
Page 5: [6] Commented [SF22]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 9:42:00 AM
Not proofreading; but which grandmother? Paternal/maternal?
Page 5: [7] Commented [SF23]
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 9:28:00 AM
Savannah Frierson
9/25/2016 9:43:00 AM
Too many “she’s” without antecedents.
Page 5: [8] Commented [SF24]
Books can be on any subject; I’d say “science” or “books, especially science books.”