Research Writing
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Is Tooth Brushing Alone Sufficient? A Clinical Study Evaluating How
Oral Hygiene is Improved with the Usage of Oral Rinse and Dental
Flossing Along Conventional Tooth Brushing
MUHAMMAD IMRAN1, REHMAN SHAHID2, DUR MOHAMMED LASHARI3
1
Assistant Professor of Community & Preventive Dentistry
Demonstrator of Operative Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry Multan
3
Associate Professor of Oral Biology Dental Section, Bolan Medical College Quetta
Correspondence to: Dr. Rehman Shahid Email:-2
ABSTRACT
Aim: To determine whether tooth brushing alone is sufficient or not beside the additional usage of CHX oral rinse
and dental flossing to obtain maximum OHI scoring.
Study Design:Descriptive study
Place and Duration of Study: Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan from 1stOctober 2017 to 31stMarch 2018.
Methods: A total of 360 patients were included. These patients were divided in three major groups, A, B, and C.
Each group was divided into 12 sub groups with each sub group having 10 patients. Complete history was taken
of every patient. Group A was directed about the manual tooth brushing technique to continue it for four months.
The group B was instructed tooth brushing along the oral rinse chlorhexidinegluconate 0.2% twice daily for four
months. The third group C was given the instructions of tooth cleaning with manual tooth brushing, oral rinse and
use of dental floss. First follow up was observed after two months and the second was at the end of fourth month.
The oral hygiene index (OHI) was measured by Debris index and Calculus Index.
Results:ANOVA shows the p<0.05. Tukey HSD equation gives the value of 0.6884.It connotes that any two
means that are more than 0.6884 are significantly different.F statistic obtained is more than 3.46. So the null
hypothesis is rejected describing the variance among the groups.
Conclusion: It is evident that all three modes of applications contribute much oral hygiene. The patients in the
community should be guided and made aware of all these oral hygiene measures in order to get the optimum
results in the good oral hygiene.
Keywords: Chlorhexidinegluconate (CHX), Dental floss, S mutans, Oral hygiene Index (OHI)
INTRODUCTION
Indeed whosoever purifies himself shall achieve
success.(Al-A’la 87:14). Of course who obeyed the
message of Holy Prophet (ﷺ
), performed the prayers and
praised the Allah (SWT) is candidate for Jannah. Islam
emphasize on the cleanliness, both physical and spiritual. It
has been an essential part of our faith. Being clean is a
guarantee for good health. While we think of our body
systems, the nature has created a unique system of
cleaning in a beautiful harmony. The oral cavity is part of
body that requires special attention to be paid for cleaning
and perfectly hygienic. Our beloved Prophet Muhammad
had a regular practice of using miswak for his blessed teeth
before every salah.
When the oral cavity is clean, the teeth would have
less chances of caries and other associated diseases. In
order to improve the oral health status it is necessary that
proper oral hygiene methods and measurements should be
the primary concern. Brushing the teeth is a common
practice to keep the teeth health and clean and it plays an
important role in the oral hygiene. No matter what the
technique is applied while brushing, a key aspect is to keep
the teeth clean and free of caries. Tooth brushing has been
an object of research since long. Over the past few
decades there has been a dramatic increase in the junk
food leading to increased demand for tooth cleaning habits.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------Received on-
Accepted on-
853 P J M H S Vol. 13, NO. 3, JUL – SEP 2019
It is known that a proper and recommended brushing
technique is necessary for cleaning the teeth. Even the
patients with regular brushing are usually found querulous
lacking oral hygiene maintenance. Most of the people are
unaware of the brushing method and they just do this by
their own understandings and cacoethes making this
practice is dime a dozen. Therefore, the patients and
people of community should be advised the technique of
tooth brushing that is recommended by the clinician. There
are a number of brushing techniques that may be adopted
according to the desire and need. These include Bass
technique, Charter’s technique, vibratory technique,
Stallman’s technique etc and many more. The objective is
to make the teeth and gingiva clean. A good executed
technique is beneficial. It helps cleaning all faces of teeth
and gingiva. These faces include buccal, lingual, occlusal
and the approximal surfaces. All these surfaces are
required to be free of plaque and calculus. It is important to
remember that there are some areas in the oral cavity
which are difficult to clean and are in a difficult approach to
the tooth brush. These are the approximal surfaces and
also pits and fissures to some extent. Interdental brushes
have been specially designed to overcome the problem
and cleaning of the approximal parts. Moreover, dental
floss has been devised to clean the interdental surfaces. It
reduces the plaque and gingivitis or both efficiently more as
compared to brushing alone.1 These floss threads are
available in different forms like threaded, untwisted, waxed
and non waxed. The purpose is same for all the materials.
Various oral rinses have also been formulated to be used in
Muhammad Imran, Rehman Shahid, Dur Mohammed Lashari
conjunction with the brushing. The dental floss and oral
rinse are usually not used commonly by the patients but
their beneficial effects can’t be disregarded. They add
much in good oral hygiene. The problem do exists in the
malformed and mal aligned teeth where not only a
particular tooth brushing technique is required but also the
approach of adopting the brush in a gentle manner. For
example the patients during orthodontic treatment may
require special attention. The Propolis mouth may add
beneficial effects in these patients2.
The adjunctive therapies in addition to mechanical
cleaning like anti plaque agents prevent plaque
accumulation3. Clinical significance of essential oil mouth
wash (Listerine) has also been reported as a positive
adjunct to mechanical cleaning4. The dental plaque is
bacterial colony. It is considered as major cause of gum
inflammation i.e., gingivitis and periodontitis5. Therefore,
plaque and calculus free teeth may contribute to improved
oral hygiene.
Table 1: Data obtained statistics
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Tukey HSD
This study was conducted at Nishtar Institute of Dentistry,
Multan from 1st October 2017 to 31st March 2018.A total of
360 patients were included. These patients were divided in
three major groups, A, B, and C. Each group was divided
into 12 sub groups with each sub group having 10 patients.
Complete history was taken of every patient. At the
beginning, complete scaling and polishing was done in
order make a baseline start of the oral hygiene
assessment. This procedure was performed in group
segments on daily basis. After the completion of scaling
and polishing, all the groups were instructed in simple
words about the manual tooth brushing technique
(Charter’s technique) and to continue it for four months.
The group B was also instructed tooth brushing along the
oral rinse chlorhexidine gluconate 0.2% twice daily for four
months. The third group C was given the instructions of
tooth cleaning with manual tooth brushing, oral rinse and
use of dental floss. All the patients in three groups were
given instructions about their respective cleansing mode.
These instructions were including the brushing techniques
and the use of dental floss. First follow up was after two
months and the second was at the end of fourth month.
The oral hygiene index (OHI) was measured by Debris
index and Calculus Index. The mean of oral hygiene index
was taken for each sub group in all three categories. After
the expiry of four months the data was tabulated using
SPSS 16 giving some interesting values.
RESULTS
The value of q is determined from the Tukey chart. The Df
is 35 (within group) with 3 groups of treatments. It finds to
be 3.4696 with alpha 0.05 in the Chart. By employing the
values in Tukey HSD equation we get the value of 0.6884.
It connotes that any two means that are more than 0.6884
are significantly different.F statistic obtained is greater than
3.46. So the null hypothesis is rejected suggesting that one
or more treatments are significantly different. Further
analysis of Tukey HSD test denotes the difference between
the three sets of applications. The group C had the most
favorable findings from the get-go.
-
Tooth
brushing
with
oral
rinse (CHX
gluconate-
Tooth
brushing
with
oral
rinse plus
flossing-
-
-
81.9014
-
0.6524
0.4225
0.3427
0.9483
0.8077
0.6500
0.5854
0.9738
0.2332
0.1876
0.1690
0.1623
Tooth
brushing
Treatment
Number
Sum ∑xi
Mean x¯
Sum of squares
∑x2i
Sample
variance s2
Sample
Std.
dev. S
Std. dev. of
mean SEx¯
Grand
Total-
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
Sum of
squares-
Groups
Between
Within
Total
Df
2
33
35
Mean
square-
F statistic
P Value
18.6204
< 0.00001
x¯A- x¯B=- =0.5325
x¯A-x¯C=- =1.6758
x¯B-x¯C=- =1.1433
DISCUSSION
Tooth brushing with proper recommended technique is
necessary for the clean oral cavity. This cleaning will be
achieved when we employ the brushing in a prescribed
way. The brushing of teeth includes cleaning of the teeth,
gingiva, palate, tongue and associated soft tissues. All
these are needed to be clean through tooth brushing.
There are however, some adjunctive have been developed
that add much contribution in the cleaning of the teeth.
Traditionally, it has been argued that application of the
dental floss, certain types of anti plaque agents and the
oral rinses are of positive value. It has also been observed
that the conventional brushing technique may sometimes
not be appropriate for what it is meant for. Sometimes there
might be an unambiguous relationship between the
brushing and flossing or the use of oral rinse. The patient
needs certain awareness about the application of the
required techniques that are meant healthy cleaning of
teeth. Inter dental areas are usually thought to be difficult to
clean by the tooth brushing. This is especially because the
approach of the tooth brush sometimes while cleaning is
not applied in a correct way by the patient. It needs a little
attention by the patient as well as by the dentist to create
awareness and make patients learn the proper way of
cleaning. The stagnation of food is more in the interdental
areas, pits and fissures and certain morphologic variations
that make the catch points on the tooth surface. While tooth
brushing, every aspect of the tooth surface is considered.
Chlorhexidine is considered the most effective in reducing
the S-mutans as well as plaque.6Other herbal formulations
of mouthwashes can also be used effectively as an
alternate to chlorhexidine mouth wash7.
Chlorhexidine mouth rinse has the anti bacterial effect
which can last for three to four hours. The results obtained
by Naiktari et al8 were statistically significant. Though the
contradictory results were observed by Garcia et al9
P J M H S Vol. 13, NO. 3, JUL – SEP-
Is Tooth Brushing Alone Sufficient?
demonstrating that stannous fluoride dentifrices and
peroxide gel are superior to the chlorhexidine mouth rinse
in reducing the gingivitis. The antibiotic resistance is also a
challenge for the prevention of certain diseases. Like its
beneficial effects in other systemic diseases, it has also a
major role in the oral cavity. Povidone Iodine (PVP-I) at
concentration of 0.23% has shown to provide the protection
against oropharyngeal infections in patients having high
risk to oral and respiratory infections10. Other side of the
coin is the adverse effect of the CHX gluconate is the
increase mineral uptake in the biofilm in oral cavity. Thus it
leads to the increase calculus formation. It has been
observed and proved by the researchers. According to
Sakayue et al11 the removal of the biofilm is necessary
before CHX use in order to minimize the increase calculus
formation as a adverse effect of the chlorhexidine
mouthwash.
A considerable amount of the literatures have been
published that reflect different author’s investigations.
Another study revealed anti plaque activity with CHX and
herbal mouthwashes.12Luíset al13 reviewed that even the
essential oil mouth rinses are more effective in reducing the
inter-proximal plaque. Flossing 2-4 days a week is as
beneficial as frequently employed flossing technique. The
higher cases of periodontitis are due to old age, smoking
and lack of regular dental checkups. In fact the dental floss
is of much help in reducing the periodontitis, a preliminary
work undertaken by Cepeda et al14.
The correct tooth cleaning is necessary and the
results of certain investigators are in accordance to those
engaged by our study. A number of people have the faulty
tooth cleaning techniques. Thus it should be emphasized
that a proper awareness is mandatory for the good oral
hygiene as pointed out by Naseem15.
A dental floss impregnated with 2% chlorhexidine has
more effectiveness in reducing the inter-proximal biofilms
as compared to the conventional floss.16 Tooth brushing is
essential for the oral health and thus preventing from caries
and gingivitis. It may be recommended twice daily for two
minutes regularly. Bain et al17 argues that both mechanical
as well as manual tooth brushes are far better and
advantageous.
It has also been known that there are some damaging
effects of the tooth brushing. Though it is necessary to
clean the teeth but it is not uncommon to observe the
damage done to the teeth due to excessive brushing
especially in the old age. The abrasive material present in
the tooth paste may result in the cervical abrasion and
chipping of the enamel. It is therefore necessary that
patient should be advised the correct brushing technique
and the required frequency. Too much cleaning is harmful
for the tooth structure18.
CONCLUSION
Tooth brushing is considered as an echt and integral part of
good oral hygiene. It depends upon the technique of the
brushing employed to get the optimum results. Meanwhile,
the addition of the chlorhexidine (CHX) gluconate rinse
adds much in reducing the plaque. A proper flossing
technique also suits much to the patients improving their
oral hygiene without a hitch. Thus, it evident from our study
that all these three classic paradigms of oral hygiene
855 P J M H S Vol. 13, NO. 3, JUL – SEP 2019
improvement contribute bendigedig. Though in our study
CHX exhibited remarkable results but it is not the only
pebble on the beach. Further investigation with different
oral rinses might show different OHI scoring. The patients
in the community should be instructed and made aware of
all these oral hygiene measures in order to get insouciant
results on good oral hygiene.
REFERENCES
1. Worthington HV, MacDonald L, Poklepovic Pericic T Home use of
interdental cleaning devices, in addition to tooth brushing, for
preventing and controlling periodontal diseases and dental caries.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2019;4:CD-. Dehghani M, Abtahi M, Hasanzadeh N. Effect of Propolis
mouthwash on plaque and gingival indices over fixed orthodontic
patients. J ClinExp Dent 2019;11(3):e244-9.
3. Chapple ILC, Van der Weijden D, Doerfer C, et al. Primary
prevention
of
periodontitis:
managing
gingivitis.
J
ClinPeriodontol2015;42(Suppl 16): S71–6.
4. Araujo MWB, Charles CA, Weinstein RB, et al. Meta-analysis of
the effect of an essential oil-containing mouthrinse on gingivitis
and plaque. J Am Dent Assoc 2015; 146: 610–22.
5. Kinane DF, Attström R. Advances in the pathogenesis of
periodontitis: group B consensus report of the fifth European
Workshop in Periodontology. J Clin Periodontol 2005; 32(Suppl
6): 130–31.
6. Padiyar B,Marwah N,Gupta S. Comparative evaluation of effects
of triphala, garlic extracts, and chlorhexidinemouthwasheson
salivary streptococcus mutans counts and oral hygiene status. Int
J ClinPediatr Dent2018;11(4):-. Vinod KS, Sunil KS, Sethi P. A novel herbal formulation versus
chlorhexidine mouthwash in efficacy against oral microflora. J
IntSocPrev Community Dent 2018;8(2):184-90.
8. Naiktari RS, Dharmadhikari C. Determining the antibacterial
substantivity of Triphala mouthwash and comparing it with 0.2%
chlorhexidinegluconateafter a single oral rinse: A crossover
clinical trial. J Indian SocPeriodontol 2018;22(6):-. Garcia-Godoy C, Rothrock JPost-prophylaxis gingivitis prevention
with two-step stannous fluoride dentifrice plus whitening gel
sequence or chlorhexidinegluconatemouthrinse. Am J Dent 2018;
31:12-9.
10. Eggers M, Koburger-Janssen T In Vitro bactericidal and virucidal
efficacy of povidone-iodine gargle/mouthwash against respiratory
and oral tract pathogens. Infect Dis Ther 2018;7(2):-. Sakaue Y, Takenaka S, Ohsumi T. The effect of chlorhexidineon
dental calculus formation: an in vitro study. BMC Oral Health
2018;18(1):52.
12. Prasad KA,John S,Deepika V Anti-plaque efficacy of herbal and
0.2% chlorhexidinegluconate mouthwash: a comparative study. J
IntOralHealth2015;7(8):-. Luís HS, Luís LS, Bernardo M Randomized controlled trial on
mouth rinse and flossing efficacy on interproximal gingivitis and
dental plaque. Int J Dent Hyg 2018;16(2):e73-8.
14. Cepeda MS, Weinstein R, Blacketer C Association of
flossing/inter-dental cleaning and periodontitis in adults. J
ClinPeriodontol 2017;44(9):-. Naseem S, Fatima SH, Ghazanfar H. Oral hygiene practices and
teeth cleaning techniques among medical students. Cureus
2017;9(7):e1487.
16. Muniz FWMG, da Silva Lima H, Rösing CK, Efficacy of an
unwaxeddental floss impregnated with 2% chlorhexidine on
control of supragingival biofilm: a randomized, clinical trial. J
InvestigClin Dent 2018;9(1):13-9.
17. Bain C, Sayed AA, Kaklamanos EG. Tooth brushing-Should We
Advise Mechanical or Power Brushes? Results of an International
Delphi Conference. J Contemp Dent Pract2018;19(10):-. Wiegand A, Schlueter N. The role of oral hygiene: does tooth
brushing harm? Monogr Oral Sci2014;25:215-9.
Original Article
COMPLICATIONS AFTER POST AND CORE TREATMENT
MUHAMMAD IMRAN
2
REHMAN SHAHID
3
MEHMOOD HUSSAIN
4
MUHAMMAD JAWAID
5
MOIN KHAN
1
ABSTRACT
Rehabilitation of worn dentitions is a big challenge. To save badly damaged teeth after endodontic treatment, provision of post and core restoration is very effective treatment option. The aim of this
study was to observe common complications associated with provision of post and core treatment for
the badly damage tooth.
In this study 95 patients reported to Oral Diagnostic Departments of Hamdard University Dental
Hospital (HUDH), Karachi and Nishtar Institute of Dentistry (NID), Multan were randomly selected.
Sixty two females and thirty three males were included in this study with age range from 18-47 years.
After taking consent, patients were evaluated by using self designed proforma after six month from
provision of post and core restorations. Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 16
was used for data analysis to find common complications linked with post and core restorations. The
most frequent complain was gingivitis which was reported in 21 patients (22.1%) followed by loss of
retention/ requirement of re cementation which was found in 15 (15.7%) patients respectively.
Key Words: Endodontic treated tooth, complications, post and core restorations, post and core failure.
INTRODUCTION
With advent of aesthetics dentistry, every individual
despite having compromised dentition wishes to have
both functional and esthetically effective restorations
in their mouth. It is difficult to restore tooth with
conventional crown once sufficient tooth structure is
lost. For restoration of such tooth multiple approaches
can be employed.1 In many such cases restoration will
be provided after completion of successful endodontic
treatment. One of the very viable treatment options
is post and core restorations. If following basic guide
lines then post and core restorations can have longevity
1
2
3
4
5
Muhammad Imran, BDS, MCPS, Assistant Professor, Department
of Community Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan
E-mail:-Cell:-
Rehman Shahid, BDS, FCPS II Trainee, Lecturer, Department of
Operative Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan
Mehmood Hussain, BDS, FCPS, Assistant Professor & Head
Department of Prosthodontics, Hamdard College of Medicine &
Dentistry, Karachi
Muhammad Javaid, BDS, MDS Trainee, Lecturer Department of
Operative Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan
Moin Khan, BDS, Lecturer Department of Prosthodontics,
Hamdard College of Medicine & Dentistry, Karachi
For Correspondence: Dr Mehmood Hussain, House No. A-695,
Block H, North Nazimabad, Karachi
E-mail:-Cell:-
Received for Publication:
May 10, 2015
Revised:
August 15, 2015
Approved:
August 21, 2015
of more than 20 years.2 Numerous varieties of posts
depending upon type of material (metal, fiber post),
shape of post (parallel or tapered), mode of action (active or passive) or mode of preparation (pre fabricated
or custom made) are readily available, each having its
characteristics advantages and disadvantages.3
Provision of specific type of post depends upon various factors like type of occlusion, presence of any parafunctional habit, location of tooth in the arch, amount of
coronal structure remains after endodontic treatment,
socioeconomic status.4 Radiographic assessment is also
of significant value as it provides valuable information
regarding root length, shape of canal, quality of root
canal treatment, presence of any periapical pathology,
periodontal status. All these factors have significant
role on the success of post and core restorations.5
After placement of post, next step is core build up,
numerous materials like glass ionomer materials including resin modified glass ionomer, cermet, amalgam, gold,
composite are available on which preparation has been
done for provision of crown.6 Provision of post reinforce
the mechanical strength of the restored tooth, the onlay/
crown component protects the endodontically treated
premolar from splitting under compressive loading
while post will not only provide adequate retention but
also protect the tooth from tensile (horizontal) stresses.7
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 3 (September 2015)
546
Complications after post and core treatment
Provision of post is associated with many complains
like caries, gingivitis, tooth fracture, post fracture, core
fracture, prosthesis fracture, loss of retention and need
for recementation. These problems must be properly
evaluated and should be corrected accordingly.8
Diagnostic Departments of Hamdard University Dental
Hospital, Karachi and Nishtar Institute of Dentistry,
Multan were selected randomly for present study. The
study was started in 2013 and was spread over 18
months.
The aim of this study was to find out the common
complications after provision of post and core restorations in patients visited Hamdard University Dental
Hospital (HUDH), Karachi and Nishtar Institute of
Dentistry (NID), Multan.
After taking consent patients were advised to visit
one week, one month and six months after provision of
post and core restoration. Self designed proforma was
used to record all relevant details after six months
extra oral and intra oral examinations were carried
out to find any complication linked with post and core
restoration.
METHODOLOGY
Initially one hundred patients reported to Oral
14
13
13
12
11
12
Age Groups
FREQUENCY
10
10
8
8
10-25
6
6
5
5
26-40
4
4
3
41-55
2
1
2
0
1
1
0
0
0
11
12
13
21
22
23
TEETH SELECTED FOR POST AND CORE
Fig 1: Teeth selected in different age groups for Post and Core Treatment
9
9
FREQUENCY
8
8
Age Groups
7
7
6
6
5
5
10-25
4
4
3
3
2
2
26-40
2
2
1
1
1
0
0
1
41-55
0
Gingivitis
Tooth Fracture
Fracture of
Core
Fracture of
Post
Recementation
COMPLICATIONS AFTER POST AND CORE TREATMENT
Fig 2: Common Complications after Post and Core Treatment
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 3 (September 2015)
547
Complications after post and core treatment
As five patients did not visit on subsequent follow
up visits, so they were excluded from the study. Therefore total ninety five patients were finally selected. Of
the selected patients, 62 (65.2%) were females while
33 males (34.7%). Age of the patient varies from 18-47
years.
Those patients who did not get any fixed prosthodontic treatment for the same tooth in past were included
in this study. Those patients who have established
uncontrolled diabetes or unable to maintain good oral
hygiene due to local or systemic reasons were also excluded from the study. Statistical Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS) version-16 was used to find common
complications linked with post and core restorations.
RESULTS
The most frequent complain was gingivitis which
was reported in 21 patients (22.1%) followed by loss of
retention / requirement of re cementation which was
found in 15 (15.7%) patients respectively. While in 06
(6.3%) patients post fracture was also reported.
DISCUSSION
Rehabilitation of anterior dentition often requires
multidisciplinary approach, provision of post and core
restoration followed by crown is still very effective
treatment. Various factors like location of tooth, shape
of root, root length, amount of coronal portion remains
after tooth preparation have strong influence for the
selection of particular type of post.9
In this study pre fabricated metal posts were used
which is similar to the study conducted by Akbar.10
Similarly Memon et al also reported a case where they
used prefabricated metal post to restore badly damaged
tooth.11
In a study reported by Schmidlin et al12 majority
of the patients (64%) were females while 24% males.
These results are similar to the present study, as frequency of females and males were 62 (65.2%) 33 (34.7%)
respectively.
In this study all impressions were made with polysiloxane impression material which is similar to the
study by Rashid where same impression material was
used during provision of post and core restoration.13
In the study the most common complain was gingivitis (22.1%) which is similar to the results obtained
in a result in a study by Jung RE et al14 where the frequency of gingivitis was 28.6%. this is contrast to the
study conducted by De Backer H et al15 where caries
(32%) was the most significant complain.
Gbadebo et al16 reported 2.5% cases of decementation in their study while in this study, rate of decementation was 15.7% which was significantly higher.
In this study all teeth are restored with porcelain fused
to metal (PFM) crowns. Ratnakar et al17 in his survey
found that majority of the endodontically treated were
restored with PFM after placement of cast post.
Fracture of post is also commonly associated complain after provision of post and core restoration. Various
factors like material, type, shape, length, diameter of
the post will determine the success of the post. In this
study, 06 patients reported with complain of fracture
of post. Pereira et al18 in their study also noticed that
incidence of post fracture was increased when metal
post was used.
Fracture of tooth itself after provision of post and
core restoration is also reported in the literature. In the
present study three cases were reported having fracture
of tooth. Use of prefabricated metal post enhanced the
fracture of tooth as compare to the cast post system.
This fact was also observed by Figueiredo et al19 in
their study that incidence of tooth fracture was double
if pre fabricated metal post was used in comparison to
studies where cast metal post was used.
The age of the patient is also a very critical factor
in determination of successful post and core restoration.
The need of recementation requirement was more in
younger age group which is linked with presence of large
number of teeth opposing arch and heavy masticatory
forces which is generally low in older age group. In the
present study 09 patients from younger age group were
need recementation while for older age group recementation was done for only 01 patient. Mentink et al20 in
their study reported that in 45% of the patients after
10 years required recementation.
The cause of failure must be identified, complete
assessment of the restoration, remaining tooth, patient’s
functional and aesthetic demands are very critical in
order to formulate a successful treatment plan.21
CONCLUSION
To restore endodontically treated teeth with post
and core restoration is linked with multiple complications. Every patient should be critically evaluated
to minimize the incidence of various complications
associated with post and core restoration.
REFERENCES
1
Goyal MK, Goyal S, Hegde V, Balkrishana D, Narayana AI.
Recreating an esthetically and functionally acceptable dentition:
a multidisciplinary approach. Int J Periodontics Restorative
Dent 2013; 33: 527-32.
2
Valderhaug J, Jokstad A, Ambjornsen E, Norheim PW. Assesment of the periapical and clinical status of crowned teeth over
25 years. J Dent 1997; 25: 97-105.
3
Wiskott HWA. Operative dentistry. Fixed Prosthodontics Principles and Clinics. 1st ed. Germany: Quintessence Publishing
2011; 289-338.
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 3 (September 2015)
548
Complications after post and core treatment
4
Al-Omari WM, AM. The retention of cast metal dowels fabricated
by direct and indirect techniques. J Prosthodont 2010; 19: 58-63.
14
Jung RE, Kalkstein O, Sailer I, Roos M, Hämmerle CH. A comparison of composite post buildups and cast gold post-and-corebuildups for the restoration of nonvital teeth after 5 to 10 years.
Int J Prosthodont 2007; 20: 63-69.
5
Bateman G, Tomson P. Trends in Indirect Dentistry: 2. Post
and Core Restorations. Dent Update 2005; 32: 190-98.
6
Al Ghadban A, Al Shaarani F. Antibacterial properties of amalgam and composite resin materials used as cores under crowns.
Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent. 2012 Jun; 20(2): 71-76.
15
De Backer H, Van Maele G, De Moor N, Van den Berghe L. An
up to 20-year retrospective study of 4-unit fixed dental prostheses for the replacement of 2 missing adjacent teeth. Int J
Prosthodont 2008; 21: 259-66.
7
Sharath Chandra SM. Sharonlay- A new onlay design for endodontically treated premolar. J Conserv Dent 2015; 18: 259-66.
16
Gbadebo OS, Ajayi DM, Oyekunle OO, Shaba PO. Randomized
clinical study comparing metallic and glass fiber post in restoration of endodontically treated teeth. Indian J Dent Res 2014;
25: 58-63.
8
Jotkowitz A, Samet N. Rethinking ferrule – a new approach to
an old dilemma. Br Dent J 2010; 209: 25-33.
9
Patil PG, Nimbalkar-Patil SP, Karandikar AB. Multidisciplinary
treatment approach to restore deep horizontally fractured maxillary central incisor. J Contem Dent Pract 2014; 15: 112-15.
17
Ratnakar P, Bhosgi R, Metta KK, Aggarwal K, Vinuta S, Singh
N. Survey on restoration of endodontically treated anterior teeth:
a questionnaire based study. Int J Oral Health 2014; 6: 41-45.
10
Akbar I. Knowledge, attitudes and practice of restoring endodontically treated teeth by dentists in north of Saudi Arabia.
Int J Health Sci 2015; 9: 41-49.
18
11
Memon MS, Khatri DR, Rehan F, Mirza D, Khan MY. Restoration of fractured maxillary central incisor of a young female
patient. J Pak Dent Assoc 2006; 15: 104-06.
Pereira JR, do Valle AL, Shiratori FK, Ghizoni JS, Bonfante
EA. The effect of post material on the characteristic strength
of fatigued endodontically treated teeth. J Prosthet Dent 2014;
112: 1225-30.
19
12
Schmidlin K, Schnell N, Steiner S, Salvi GE, Pjetursson B, Matuliene G, Zwahlen M, Brägger U, Lang NP. Complication and
failure rates in patients treated for chronic periodontitis and
restored with single crowns on teeth and/or implants. Clin Oral
Implants Res 2010; 21: 550-57.
Figueiredo FE, Martins-Filho PR, Faria-E-Silva AL. Do metal post-retained restorations result in more root fractures than
fiberpost-retained restorations? A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Endod 2015; 41: 309-16.
20
Mentink AG, Meeuwissen R, Käyser AF, Mulder J. Survival
rate and failure characteristics of all the metal post and core
restoration. J Oral rehab 1993; 20: 455-61.
21
Beddis HP, Okechukwu N, Nattress BR. The last post: assessment of the failing post-retained crown. Dent Update 2014; 41:
386-88.
13
Saqib Rashid. Restoration of an extensively broken down Maxillary Molar with Cast Split Post and Core. A Case Report. J
Pak D Assoc 2001; 10: 54-55.
CONTRIBUTION BY AUTHORS
1
2
3
4
5
Muhammad Imran:
Rehman Shahid:
Mehmood Hussain:
Muhammad Jawaid:
Moin Khan:
Collection of data & biostatistics.
Collection of material for writing introduction.
Data collection of patients, helped in writing introduction.
Data collection of patients from Multan & bibliography writing.
Biostatistics.
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 3 (September 2015)
549
Original Article
PATTERN OF ORAL HYGIENE MAINTENANCE AMONG PATIENTS SEEN
AT TWO TERTIARY HOSPITALS
SYED ABRAR ALI
REHMAN SHAHID
3
MEHMOOD HUSSAIN
4
MUHAMMAD IMRAN
5
MOIN KHAN
1
2
ABSTRACT
The study was conducted in two tertiary hospitals to observe frequency & duration of tooth
brushing & their relation with incidence of caries, gingivitis & sensitivity. In this study total 1200
patients were selected randomly reported to Department of Operative Dentistry of both institutes. The
duration of study was one year. Out of these 1200 patients 755 (62.91%) were male and 445 (37.08%)
were female with age range from 15- 74 years. All patients were divided into three groups on the basis
of their age, in group 1 age range was 15-25 years, in group 2 age range was 26-50 years while group
3 included patients of above 50 years.
After taking consent from the patients a self designed questionnaire was used to get necessary
details. Data compiling and statistical analysis was done by using SPSS – 20 & results were obtained.
Brushing frequency and duration of brushing is better in group 2 followed by group 1 & 3
respectively. The rate of caries and gingivitis is also significantly higher in group 2 (50.8% & 40.4%)
followed by group 1 (21.6% & 15%) and group 3 (1.8% & 2.5%) respectively.
Key Words: Caries, gingivitis, sensitivity, frequency & duration of brushing.
INTRODUCTION
Good oral hygiene is one of the primary indicators
of overall general health. In literature so much information is available on different methods to maintain
good oral hygiene but unfortunately these methods
are not properly practiced, as a result incidence of
various oral health disorders are continuously increasing.1
1
2
3
4
5
Syed Abrar Ali, Assistant Professor & Head Department of
Operative Dentistry, Hamdard College of Medicine & Dentistry,
Karachi E-mail:-Cell:-
Rehman Shahid, Lecturer Department of Operative Dentistry,
Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan
Mehmood Hussain, Associate Professor & Head Department
of Prosthodontics, Hamdard College of Medicine & Dentistry,
Karachi
Muhammad Imran, Assistant Professor, Department of Community Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry
Moin Khan, Lecturer Department of Prosthodontics, Hamdard
College of Medicine & Dentistry, Karachi
For Correspondence: Syed Abrar Ali, 359-B Block, Adamji
Nagar, Karachi
Email:-Cell:-
Received for Publication:
August 27, 2015
Revised:
October 8, 2015
Approved:
October 11, 2015
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 4 (December 2015)
To maintain good oral hygiene proper tooth brushing is one of the simpler and easy way but still it is
not properly practiced in our community. There are
numerous brushing techniques like Bass, Stillmans,
Leonard, Smith-Bell, Fones and Charters etc which
are discussed in the literature. Each technique has
its own advantages and disadvantages.2 Apart from
brushing technique frequency of tooth brushing, total
duration of tooth brushing, type of tooth brush, quality
of tooth paste are also very significant factors in order
to maintain good oral hygiene.3 Use of other cleansing
aids like dental floss, interdental brushes, fluoride
application and varnishes are also some significant
factors in this regard.4
Faulty and irregular tooth brushing technique
are directly related to increase incidence of various
oral health disorders especially caries and gingivitis
which will ultimately lead to loss of teeth.5 Bad oral
hygiene not only affect the oral cavity but it can also
contribute to other systemic diseases like cardiovascular diseases, prosthetic joint infections etc.6 This
study was conducted to obtain information about
frequency of tooth brushing and their relation with
certain oral health problems in patients visited two
different tertiary care hospitals.
645
Pattern of oral hygiene maintenance
METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted at Department of Operative Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan
and Department of Operative Dentistry, Hamdard University Dental Hospital, Karachi. The duration of this
study was one year from 1st April 2014 to 31st March
2015. Total 1200 patients (600 from each institute) were
selected randomly reported to Department of Operative
Dentistry of both institutes. Out of these 1200 patients
755 (62.91%) were male and 445 (37.08%) were female
with age range from 15-74 years. All patients were
divided into three groups on the basis of their age,
in group 1 age range was 15-25 years, in group 2 age
range was 26-50 years while group 3 included patients
of above 50 years.
After taking consent from the patients a self designed questionnaire was used to get necessary details.
Data collection and statistical analysis was done using
SPSS – 20 and results were obtained.
RESULTS
Brushing frequency and duration of brushing is
better in group 2 followed by group 1 and 3 respectively.
The rate of caries and gingivitis is also significantly
higher in group 2 (50.8% and 40.4%) followed by group
1 (21.6% and 15%) and group 3 (1.8% and 2.5%) respectively as shown in Table 1.
DISCUSSION
Good oral hygiene is a primary requisite for having
better general health. There are numerous aids available for maintaining good oral hygiene. Using proper
tooth paste with adequate brushing technique, brushing
frequency and timing of brushing are important factors
required for having good oral health.7
Parera et al8 reported that by using proper tooth
paste with adequate brushing frequency are directly
related with good oral hygiene. The incidence of caries
and tooth loss was significantly higher in those individuals who did not brush their teeth properly. This
is also found in this study. The brushing frequency
and duration of brushing are the two most important
factors for maintaining good oral hygiene. Peker et al9
observed in their study that brushing frequency and oral
hygiene is better in young population as compared to
the older population. The similar results were obtained
in this study as well. The sample size of both studies
were also same.
Apart from manual tooth brush now days some special types of tooth brush like inter dental tooth brush,
electrically operated tooth brushes are also available
but their use is restricted in specific type of population.
In this study, majority of the population used manual
tooth brush. Field et al10 reported that in their study
the use of both manual and electric tooth brush was
effective in maintaining good oral hygiene.
In this study, the incidence of brushing twice was
28.7% which closely matches with the study of Peeran
et al11 conducted in Libian population. This is in contrast to the study of Ganss et al12 where frequency of
brushing twice was 79.6%.
Peterson et al13 noted in their study that frequency of tooth brushing is generally high in younger age
groups as compared to older age group which is mainly
due to high esthetics demand of younger population.
Similar findings were also observed in this study. In
the present study, 71.2% were doing tooth brushing
for more than 2 minutes while 28.7% had duration of
less than two minutes, while Albertsson et al14 noted
in their study that duration of tooth brushing for more
than 2 minutes was 41% and less than 2 minutes was
40.1%.
The overall incidence of caries in this study was
74.3% which is significantly high, the incidence of
caries in younger age group was 50.8% which is much
higher than the elderly population which is only 1.8%.
This result may be because of consumption of different
variety of foods, faulty brushing technique, deposition of
more secondary population in older population.. These
findings were also noted by Chu et al15 where caries
incidence is low in elderly population. This is in contrast
to the study of Zubiene et al where incidence of caries
was higher in older age group which was 25.6%.16
In the current study, 21.6% of the middle age group
individuals had been found with carious teeth while
TABLE 1: STATISTICS SHOWING FREQUENCY, DURATION OF TOOTH BRUSH, CARIES &
GINGIVITIS IN DIFFERENT AGE GROUPS
S.
Age in
No. years
Brushing
Frequency
Brushing Time
1
2
3
Less than More than
2 min
2 min
Gender
M
F
Caries
Gingivitis
Sensitivity
1
15-25
210
138
42
80
310
203
187
260
180
95
2
26-50
480
169
90
215
524
509
230
610
485
121
3
Above 50
28
38
05
50
21
43
28
22
31
18
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 4 (December 2015)
646
Pattern of oral hygiene maintenance
BRUSHING-
FREQUENCY
500
400
-
210
200
138
15-25 Age
- Age
90
100
38
28
80
50
42
21
5
Above 50
0
1
2
3
Less than 2 min
Brushing Frequency
More than 2
min
Brushing Time
Fig 1: Frequency & duration of brushing in different age groups
Pattern of Caries, Gingivitis & Sensitivity in different age groups-
Caries
Gingivitis
15-25 Age
26-50 Age
Sensitivity
Above 50 Age
Fig 2: Pattern of caries, gingivitis and sensitivity in different age groups
Chen et al17 in their study found that incidence of caries
in middle age group was 37.9%. The low frequency of
brushing and faulty brushing technique will also affect
the periodontal status of the existing dentition as well.
In this study the incidence of gingivitis is 57.9% while
Natto et al18 in their study conducted in population of
Chad noted the incidence was 56.6% which is in close
relation with this study. Darby et al noted in their study
conducted on Australian population that the incidence
of gingivitis was 28.4%.19
The incidence of sensitivity in the present study was
19.5% with higher incidence in younger age as compare
to older age group, which is mainly due to deposition of
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 4 (December 2015)
secondary dentine and consumption of particular type
of diet. The prevalence of hypersensitivity was 12.3%
in the study conducted by Cunha et al20 in American
population. Their results are also similar to this study
where rate of hypersensitivity was low in elderly population. Sadaf et al21 in their study conducted in selected
patients reported to tertiary care hospital of Karachi
found the incidence of hypersensitivity was 38% which
is significantly higher as compare to the current study.
The study was conducted to observe the teeth brushing pattern both in terms of duration and frequency.
With limitation of the sample size in this study, it was
observed that in general oral health of our population
647
Pattern of oral hygiene maintenance
is not adequate. There is an immense need to improve
the oral health of our community by increasing the
awareness about effects of good and poor oral hygiene
on oral cavity as well as on general health. Regular
educational programe for general public should be organized by the public and private organizations. Oral
health care provider can also play a significant role in
this regard.22
CONCLUSION
In general the oral hygiene of the studied population is not adequate which is linked with decrease
duration and low frequency of tooth brushing. Dentists
can play a vital role in improvement of oral hygiene of
the population.
10
Peker K, Bermek G. Oral health: locus of control, health behavior, self-rated oral health and socio-demographic factors in
Istanbul adults. Acta Odontol Scand 2011; 69: 54-64.
11
Fjeld KG, Mowe M, Eide H, Willumsen T. Effect of electric
toothbrush on residents'oral hygiene: a randomized clinical
trial in nursing homes. Eur J Oral Sci 2014; 122: 142-48.
12
Peeran SW, Singh AJ, Alagamuthu G, Abdalla KA, Naveen
Kumar PG. Descriptive analysis of toothbrushing used as an
aid for primary prevention: a population-based study in Sebha,
Libya. Soc Work Public Health 2013; 28: 575-82.
13
Ganss C, Schlueter N, Preiss S, Klimek J. Tooth brushing habits
in uninstructed adults--frequency, technique, duration and force.
Clin Oral investing 2009; 13: 203-8.
14
Petersen PE, Kandelman D, Arpin S, Ogawa H. Global oral
health of older people call for public health action. Community
Dent Health 2010; 27: 257-67.
15
Albertsson KW, van Dijken JW. Awareness of toothbrushing and
dentifrice habits in regularly dental care receiving adults. Swed
Dent J 2010; 34: 71-78.
REFERENCES
1
Kidd E. Caries control from cradle to grave. Dent Update 2010;
37: 654-56.
16
2
Graetz C, Bielfeldt J, Wolff L, Springer C, El-Sayed KM, Sälzer
S, Badri-Höher S, Dörfer CE. Toothbrushing education via a
smart software visualization system. J Periodontol 2013; 84:
186-95.
Chu CH, Ng A, Chau AM, Lo EC. Oral health status of elderly
Chinese with dementia in Hong Kong. Oral Health Prev Dent
2015; 13: 51-57.
17
Zubiene J, Milciuviene S, Klumbiene J. Evaluation of dental
care and the revalence of tooth decay among middle-aged and
elderly population of Kaunas city. Stomatologija 2009; 11: 42-47.
3
Creeth JE, Gallagher A, Sowinski J, Bowman J, Barrett K, Lowe
S, Patel K, Bosma ML. The effect of brushing time and dentifrice
on dental plaque removal in vivo. J Dent Hyg 2009; 83: 111-16.
18
Chen X, Liu Y, Yu Q, Zheng L, Hong X, Yan F, Yu H. Dental
caries status and oral health behavior among civilian pilots.
Aviat Space Environ Med 2014; 85: 99- 1004.
4
Rogers HJ, Morgan AG, Batley H, Deery C. Why, what and
how: caries control for erupting molars. Dent Update 2010; 42:
154-56.
19
Natto ZS, Petersen FF, Niccola Q. The oral health status and
the treatment needs in Chad: a pilot study. Niger Postgrad Med
J 2014; 21: 245-49.
5
Broadbent JM, Thomson WM, Boyens JV, Poulton R Dental
plaque and oral health during the first 32 years of life. J Am
dent Assoc 2011; 142: 415-26.
20
Darby I, Phan L, Post M. Periodontal health of dental clients
in a community health setting. Aust Dent J 2012; 57: 486-92.
6
Worsley DJ, Marshman Z. Few studies addressing tooth brushing
frequencu and periodontitits. Evid Based Dent 2015; 16: 15.
21
7
Mougeot FK, Saunders SE, Brennan MT, Lockhart PB. Associations between bacteremia from oral sources and distant-site
infections: tooth brushing versus single tooth extraction. Oral
Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol 2015; 119: 430-5.
Cunha-Cruz J, Wataha JC, Heaton LJ, Rothen M, Sobieraj
M, Scott J, Berg J. The prevalence of dentin hypersensitivity
in general dental practices in the northwest United States. J
Am Dent assoc 2013; 144: 288-96.
22
Sadaf D, Ahmad Z. Role of Brushing and Occlusal Forces in
Non-Carious Cervical Lesions (NCCL). Int J Biomed Sci 2014;
10: 265-68.
8
Prado RL, Saliba NA, Garbin CA, Moimaz SA. Oral impacts on
the daily performance of Brazilians assessed using a sociodental
approach: analyses of national data. Braz Oral Res 2015; 29:
1-9.
23
Wu A, Switzer-Nadasdi R. The role of health behavior in preventing dental caries in resource-poor adults: a pilot intervention.
J Tenn Dent Assoc 2014; 94: 17- 21.
9
Perera R, Ekanayake L. Tooth loss in Sri Lankan adults. Int
Dent J 2011; 61: 7-11.
CONTRIBUTION BY AUTHORS
1
2
3
4
5
Syed Abrar Ali:
Rehman Shahid:
Hasnain Abbas:
Mehmood Hussain:
Muhammad Imran:
Wrote manuscript and examining patients.
Collection of data.
Examining patients.
Assistance in inferences.
Biostatistics.
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 35, No. 4 (December 2015)
648
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Tooth Morphology and Aesthetics While Smiling in Accordance
to Golden Proportion
1
2
SHER MUHAMMAD , REHMAN SHAHID , MUHAMMAD ISMAIL SIDDIQUI
3
ABSTRACT
Background: The anterior teeth have a great impact on personality. This is true because the anterior
teeth are visible while smiling and talking. Moreover the aesthetics demand of the patients for anterior
teeth while these are getting restored by the dentist, the restorative procedure may become a bit tricky
needing a more handful of art and science that may fulfill the patient’s desires. Thus it is sometimes
more challenging to materialize the outcome that the patient actually wants. The Golden proportion is
the ratio that is found to exist between the maxillary anterior teeth while looking from the front. This
ratio has been assumed to be an ideal proportion between the maxillary anterior teeth. It may be
helpful while restoring the anterior teeth and evaluation of esthetics.
Aim: To evaluate the existence of Golden proportions in outdoor patients coming at Nishtar Institute of
Dentistry, Multan.
Methods: This study was carried out at Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan. A total 70 patients were
selected aged between 25 to 35 years. Twenty patients were male and 50 were female. The size of
anterior maxillary teeth while smiling was measured with the help of manual caliper. All the
measurements were noted in accordance to Golden proportions.
Results: Instead of golden proportion the ratio of 1.3 and 1.4 were more common i.e. 30% and 28.50%
respectively among the patients.
Conclusion: Golden proportion is not a common finding in the study group involving the local
population.
Key words: Golden proportion, Esthetics, Restorative intervention.
INTRODUCTION
The Holy Prophet ( )ﷺsaid: "When you smile to
your brother's face, it is charity". This is an authentic
hadith. It is mentioned in Sunan al-Tirmidhi. There is
enormous wisdom in the Holy Prophet’s ( )ﷺwords.
A beautiful smile is the most attractive feature in the
face. However beauty is not absolute and is
extremely subjective. A smile may be an emotional
gift or blessing, not a material one. It is a sign of joy
and pleasure. It is a gift whose recreation is received
by the heart. Smiling aids our mental as well as
physical health. The neurotransmitters like dopamine,
endorphins and serotonin are all released when a
smile given across the face1. Indeed doctors have
begun to incorporate smiling into their therapies.
Smiling contributes to lowering blood pressure
improved circulation and the beauty. It boosts the
immune system. It works wherever stress and
depression cause harm. Smiling relaxes us and
improves our emotional stability. Aesthetics is derived
----------------------------------------------------------------------1
Assistant Professor, Oral Biology & Tooth Morphology,
3
Demonstrator, Senior Dental Surgeon,
Department of Operative Dentistry, Nishtar Institute of
Dentistry Multan
Correspondence to Dr. Muhammad Ismail Siddiqui
Email:-2
from the Greek word aisthetikos that means to sense
perception2. It is the branch of philosophy concerned
with the study of concepts like as beauty, taste, etc.
Generally people are more conscious about their
smile and thus aesthetic looks. If a patient has lost
the anterior tooth/teeth, he is most conscious about
his aesthetics or smile. In this way the patient may
feel a psychological sense of being deprived and
unable to talk or smile in an open way or according to
desire. Thus a good aesthetics is somewhat a good
smile that in turns dependent on the harmonious
anterior teeth of face. It has also been observed that
the patients that require the anterior teeth
restorations take a keen interest in the outcome of
the treatment and discuss all the procedure with the
doctor before going to start as he uses all where
withal. Thus it becomes somewhat more challenging
to the doctor especially when the patient has missing
or decayed teeth3. It all denotes that anterior teeth
play a vital role in the personality and psychological
attitude of the patient. An eloquent briefing to the
patient about the treatment is sometimes more
helpful. It is also to be noted that the congenitally
missing laterals are accommodated making canines
dissemble giving looks of laterals giving a good
contribution to fetching aesthetics. The entire
evocative treatment plan is to be is predetermined. If
P J M H S Vol. 10, NO. 1, JAN – MAR-
Tooth Morphology and Aesthetics While Smiling in Accordance to Golden Proportion
the patient is satisfied from the treatment outcome
the dentist may have a good cynosure. The size and
shape of maxillary anterior teeth is of utmost
importance while considering the aesthetics and the
4
smile .
The length and width both are important for
considering the restoration. There has been
mesiodistal dimension and the incisogingival one.
Both are to be kept in mind as how to restore in the
most acceptable fashion. The width of the tooth
matters most than the other dimensions5. The patient
will be satisfied when all the restorative procedures
coincide with the natural aesthetic looks. It was Mark
Barr, an American mathematician who represented
the Golden Ratio by using a Greek symbol Φ. The
ideal proportion for aesthetics and symmetry was
6
found to be lie in the ratio of 0.618 to 1.0 . The
Golden proportion is a constant Ratio between the
larger and the smaller teeth. This ratio is
approximately 1.618:1. According to this ratio the
smaller anterior tooth is nearly 62% of the adjacent
larger tooth. This proportion was first introduced by
Euclid. While smiling the anterior teeth are visible. So
the people are more conscious about their anterior
teeth than posterior ones. The lost anterior teeth may
compromise the smile and aesthetics. The main
factors responsible for the aesthetics are the lip line,
angulations of teeth, facial symmetry, incisal line and
shade of teeth7. Special focus is also given when
restoring these anterior teeth. A lot of restorative
materials are available that are used to restore the
lost tooth part for the conservation. Special
consideration is given to match the excellence of
aesthetics and a good harmony among all the
anterior teeth. Since the aesthetics is of prime focus,
the quality of restorative procedure as well as the
material maters much. The objective of this study is
to find out the natural proportions of the anterior teeth
in comparison to golden proportion.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was conducted at Nishtar Institute of
Dentistry, Multan. Seventy patients were selected out
of which fifty were females and twenty were males.
Manual vernier calliper was used to measure the
tooth dimensions in accordance with the Golden
proportion. The width of maxillary incisors was made
from the mesiodistal contact points. The width of
canine was measured from the mesial contact point
to the most distal point visible from front side. For the
sake of good study finding and preventing any in
accuracy, each measurement was taken thrice by the
same operator. The width of larger central incisor
was multiplied by 62 percent as compared to the
smaller laterals and canines. The results were
282 P J M H S Vol. 10, NO. 1, JAN – MAR 2016
analyzed using SPSS version 20 at α=0.05. Various
ratios of golden proportions were measured on the
basis of sex. Inclusion criteria was followed as (a)
normal healthy teeth with no dental anomaly or tooth
size discrepancy, (b) no periodontal disease or gum
recession, (c) no spacing or crowding of teeth, (d) no
restorative treatment performed in anterior teeth
under consideration, (e) no attrition, erosion or
abrasion present and (f) no missing anterior teeth.
RESULTS
Instead of golden proportion the ratio of 1.3 and 1.4
were more common i.e. 30% and 28.5% respectively.
The ratio of 1.5 and 1.6 were found 11.42% and
18.57% respectively. Among the ratio of 1.6 it was
observed that females had more ideal relation of
golden proportion i.e., 22% as compared to the males
having 10%. The overall proportion of Golden
proportion was 18.57%. The prevalence of Golden
proportion in females was 22% and in males it was
10%. In males the ratio of 1.4 was 35% as compared
to females having 28.5%. However, in females the
ratio of 1.3 was more common i.e. 30% which was
equal to males (Table 1).
Table 1: Frequency and percentage of Golden proportion in
the study group
Ratio
Male
Female
Total
1.1:1
1(5%)
1.42
1.2:1
2(10%)
5(10%)
10.0
1.3:1
6(30%)
15(30%)
30.0
1.4:1
7(35%)
13(26%)
28.5
1.5:1
2(10%)
6(12%)
11.42
1.6:1
2(10%)
11(22%)
18.57
DISCUSSION
The dental and facial aesthetics has usually been
defined in terms of macro and micro elements. Macro
aesthetics correlates the interrelationships between
the face, lips, gingiva, and teeth and the perception
that these relationships usually present. Micro
aesthetics involves the aesthetics of an individual
tooth and the perception that the color and form are
appealing. The dentolabial gingival relationship,
which is considered a part of oral aesthetics, has
traditionally been where treatment planning is
initiated. This process begins by determining ideal
maxillary incisal edge placement in the jaw. This is
accomplished by understanding the incisal edge
position relative to several different landmarks in the
oral cavity. The following things are considered
preliminary to determine ideal incisal edge position
(a) the exact placement of maxillary incisors looking
aesthetically pleasing, (b) the need for any restorative
or orthodontic intervention required for aesthetics (c)
Sher Muhammad, Rehman Shahid, Muhammad Ismail Siddiqui
the proper dimensions of tooth display statically as
well as dynamically and (d) tooth size, length and
arch size all in accordance to facial symmetry. The
relationship among the teeth, or arch form, involves
the golden proportion and position of tooth width.
Although it is aesthetically pleasing yet it seldom
reflects natural tooth proportions. According to a
study, the natural portions demonstrate a lateral
incisor between 60 to 70 percent of the width of the
central incisor, which is larger than the golden
proportion6. However a rule guiding proportion is that
the canine and all teeth distal should be perceived to
occupy less visual space as we look from the frontal
aspect. Another rule to help maintain proportions
throughout the arch is 1-2-3-4-5; the lateral is 2/3 of
the central and the canine is 4/5 of the lateral, with
some latitude within those spaces. Finally, contact
areas can be moved restoratively that may coincide
the aesthetics outcomes.
According to a study, the golden proportion was
not found between perceived mesiodistal widths of
maxillary central and lateral incisors and nor between
perceived mesiodistal widths of maxillary lateral
incisors and canines. In the majority of subjects, the
width-to-height ratio of maxillary central incisor was
within 75%-80%. Moreover there were no statistically
significant differences in maxillary anterior teeth
proportions between males and females. These
results may serve as guidelines for treatment
planning in restorative dentistry and periodontal
surgery8. The aim of this study was to determine the
prevalence of Golden proportion and recurring
aesthetic dental proportions in individuals with
attractive smiles attending the OPD at Nishtar
Institute of Dentistry Multan. Seventy patients with
natural dentition were selected out of which 20 were
males and 50 were females aged 25-35.
The smiles were analysed to evaluate the
prevalence of Golden Proportion and obtained data
was statistically analyzed. In a study of evaluation
Golden Proportion, Recurring Aesthetic dental
proportion (RED) proportion was present in 6.6% of
population as opposed to golden proportion which
was found in 0.6% of population. It was found that
70% RED was more prevalent than Golden
Proportion in attractive as well as unattractive
smiles.9 Our study demonstrates that the Golden
proportion is not common in the local population. It
was found to be more common in females than males
attending the outdoor department of dental hospital.
It is also to be noted that the tooth, arch size and
the inter-arch relationships are all specific for a
certain population thus having predilection for the
certain population and the gender. In this way the
Golden proportion may be variable10,11,12. According
13
to the research of Hasanreisoglu et al about the
width of anterior teeth among Turkish population, it
was found that the dimensions of the central incisors
and canines had certain variations by gender without
the Golden proportion.
There has been no evidence pointing out that
the golden proportion should be considered the ideal
aesthetic standard when creating space for the
14.
replacement of the missing lateral incisors
12
According to Gillen et al the golden proportion was
rarely observed in his study group with 54 individuals
only using dental casts to measure Golden
proportion. Other studies have also shown that the
frequency of the golden proportion in smiles was
quite low15. The study of Woelfel16 also showed that
Golden Proportion had not always been common
phenomena and variations had been frequently
observed. On the basis of results obtained in our
study group and on the results from the different
researches17,18. We may conclude that Golden
Proportion should not be considered and ideal
parameter for every case but rather a range. The
work of Ahmed19 revealed that golden ratio can be a
good starting point in order to obtain aesthetically
acceptable results, however any ratio of 0.6-0.8 may
be aesthetically acceptable. The golden ratio can be
helpful to achieve aesthetic restorations of the
maxillary central and lateral incisors. However, the
golden ratio between the perceived widths of the
maxillary lateral incisors to the canines does not
seem to be decisive for an attractive smile and other
factors should be considered17. According to de
Castro et al18 the golden proportion was not often
found in adjacent teeth shown in smiles in the sample
19
studied. Works of Mahshid et al also demonstrated
that the golden proportion is not a common factor in
aesthetic smiles.
CONCLUSION
Golden proportion is not a common finding in the
study group. Although the Golden proportion is
helpful for the felicity of the aesthetic restorations yet
it should never be considered as a part and parcel for
every aesthetic outcome. It might be good for one
scenario but may remain superfluous for the next
one. It would be better to think the Golden proportion
as a range which might be adjusted according to both
the patient’s as well as doctor’s judgment.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
Land RD. Neural correlates of conscious emotional
experience. In: lane RD, Nadel L, eds. Cognitive
neuroscience of emotion. New York: Oxford University
Press, 2000; pp. 345–70.
The Basics of Philosophy, http://www. Philosophy
basics.com/
P J M H S Vol. 10, NO. 1, JAN – MAR-
Tooth Morphology and Aesthetics While Smiling in Accordance to Golden Proportion
3.
Curtis DA, Lacy A, Chu R, Richards D, Plesh O,
Kasrovi P et al. Treatment planning in the 21st century:
What’s new? Oral Health. 2003; 93(6):43-55.
4. Wolfart S, Brunzel S, Freitag S, Kern M. Assessment
of dental appearance following changes in incisor
angulation. Int J Prosthodont 2004; 17(2):150-4.
5. Ahmad I. Anterior dental aesthetics: Dental
perspective. Br Dent J 2005; 199(3):135-41.
6. Ricketts RM. The biologic significance of the divine
proportion and Fibonacci series. Am J Orthod 1982
May; 81(5):351-70.
7. Davis NC. Smile design. Dent Clin North Am 2007;
51(2):-. Sandeep N, Satwalekar P, Srinivas S, Reddy CS,
Reddy GR, Reddy BA. An analysis of maxillary anterior
teeth dimensions for the existence of golden
proportion: clinical study. J Int Oral Health 2015;
7(9):18-21.
9. Meshramkar R, Patankar A, Lekha K, Nadiger R. A
study to evaluate the prevalence of golden proportion
and RED proportion in aesthetically pleasing smiles.
Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent 2013; 21(1):29-33.
10. Ahmad I. Anterior dental aesthetics: dental
perspective. Br Dent J 2005; 199(3):-. Ricketts RM. The biologic significance of the divine
proportion and Fibonacci series. Am J Orthod 1982;
81(5):351-70.
284 P J M H S Vol. 10, NO. 1, JAN – MAR 2016
12. Gillen RJ, Schwartz RS, Hilton TJ, Evans DB. An
analysis of selected normative tooth proportions. Int J
Prosthodont 1994; 7(5):410-7.
13. Hasanreisoglu U, Berksun S, Aras K, Arslan I. An
analysis of maxillary anterior teeth: facial and dental
proportions. J Prosthet Dent 2005; 94(6):530-8.
14. Bukhary SM, Gill DS, Tredwin CJ, Moles DR. The
influence of varying maxillary lateral incisor dimensions
on perceived smile aesthetics. Br Dent J 2007;
203(12):-. deCastro MV, Santos NC, Ricardo LH. Assessment of
the “golden proportion” in agreeable smiles.
Quintessence Int 2006;37(8):-. Smith SS, Buschang PH, Watanabe E. Interarch tooth
size relationships of 3 populations: “does Bolton’s
analysis apply?” Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop
2000; 117(2):-. Nikgoo A, Alavi K, Alavi K, Mirfazaelian A. Assessment
of the golden ratio in pleasing smiles. World J Orthod
2009; 10(3):224-8.
18. de Castro MV, Santos NC, Ricardo LH. Assessment of
the "golden proportion" in agreeable smiles.
Quintessence Int 2006; 37(8):-. Mahshid M, Khoshvaghti A, Varshosaz M, Vallaei N.
Evaluation of "golden proportion" in individuals with an
aesthetic smile. J Esthet Restor Dent 2004; 16(3):18592.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Root and Canal Morphology of Human Primary Molars in a Local
Population of Southern Punjab: an in vitro Study
SHER MUHAMMAD1, REHMAN SHAHID2, MUHAMMAD ISMAIL SIDDIQUI3
ABSTRACT
Background: The root canal is a procedure in which whole of the diseased pulp is removed and the
canal is filled with an inert material. Therefore the success of root canal is mainly dependant on
making the entire root canal system free of micro-organisms.
Aim: To evaluate and asses the number of root canals and root curvatures present in primary
maxillary and mandibular first molars that got extraction at Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan.
Methods: This prospective study was carried at Nishtar Institute of Dentistry Multan from June 2014
to August 2014. A total 60 primary molars were taken randamly out of that 30 were maxillary first
molars and 30 were mandibular first molars. After extraction, the teeth were cleaned under running
tap water to make them free of blood clots and debris. Ultrasonic scaler was used to remove the hard
tissue attached to the teeth. The teeth were then put in glass container filled with the distilled water
and the number, length and angulation of all the roots were measured. Access cavities were prepared
using a fissure diamond bur (SF 12 Mani Japan) used in air turbine (NSK Japan) for penetration into
the pulp chamber and Endo Z bur (E0152, 21mm Mani Japan) having non-cutting end for de-roofing.
Results: Most of the teeth in the mandibular first molar had two roots. The two canals (90%) in the
mesial root and one canal in the distal root (86.66%). The mean length of the mesial root was 8.99mm
and mean angulation was 10.80o. The mean length of the distal root of mandibular molar was 7.10mm
and the root angulation that of 8.10o .All the maxillary molars had three roots. Although a few had
distobuccal and palatal roots fused yet the canals were completely separated. The mesiobuccal root
of maxillary molar showed the maximum mean angulation of 18.740 followed by distobuccal and
palatal having the mean angulation of 15.410 and 12.490 respectively.
Conclusion: All the root canals of maxillary first molars are separated and the palatal canal being the
longest one and straight. The mandibular first molars have two roots and three canals. The distal root
being longer than mesial one. No specific aberrations were found.
Keywords: Root canal, Root angulation, Zipping, Ledge, Perforation, Primary molars
INTRODUCTION
`
Dental caries is a very chronic bacterial disease
leading to the disintegration of the organic and
inorganic components of teeth. The destruction of the
tooth tissue is due to the acid production. The
deciduous teeth are the primary teeth present in the
oral cavity during childhood. Primary teeth are
considered essential in the development of the oral
cavity. The permanent teeth replacements develop
from the same tooth germs as the primary teeth,
which provide guides for permanent teeth eruptions.
Also the muscles of the jaw and the formation of the
jaw bones depend on the primary teeth in order to
maintain proper spacing for permanent teeth in oral
cavity. The roots of primary teeth provide a salient
--------------------------------------------------------------------1
Assistant Professor, Department of Oral Biology & Tooth
Morphology, Nishtar Institute of Dentistry Multan,
2
Demonstrator, Department of Operative Dentistry, Nishtar Institute
of Dentistry Multan.,
3
Senior Dental Surgeon, Department of Operative Dentistry,
Nishtar Institute of Dentistry, Multan
Correspondence to Dr. Muhammad Ismail Siddiqui, Email:-
feature, an opening for the senescence permanent
teeth to erupt. The primary teeth are also mandatory
for proper development of a child's speech and
chewing of food. The tradition of throwing a baby
tooth up into the sky to the sun or to Allah and asking
for a better tooth to replace it is common in Middle
Eastern countries (including Iraq, Jordan, Egypt and
Sudan). It may have been originated in a pre-Islamic
offering and certainly dates back to at least the 13th
century, when Izz bin Hibat Allah Al Hadid mentions
1
it. In old Britain, lost teeth were commonly burnt to
destroy them. This was partly for religious reasons
connected with the Last Judgement and partly for
fear of what might happen if an animal got them. A
2
rhyme might be said as a blessing. The treatment of
primary and young permanent teeth is quite safe and
predictable, that has been approached by a lot of
research detailing the best clinical techniques helping
the clinical practices. With sound clinical techniques
and some rather extraordinary compounds, splendid
can be done to save baby teeth. As always,
treatment is based on assessment and diagnosis,
though the diagnosis being much important,
P J M H S Vol. 9, NO. 3, JUL – SEP-
Root and Canal Morphology of Human Primary Molars in a Local Population of Southern Punjab
especially in the case of primary teeth, may be
decided by the state of the tooth at the time of
examination and treatment. What’s necessary is a
thorough knowledge and state-of-the art treatment
techniques for the various stages of pulpal
involvement for milk teeth with trauma and caries.
The main object of the erudite clinician is to appease
the patient regarding the specific treatment protocol
whatsoever has been chosen. In the same way any
failure in the desired treatment may be of much
fractious both for the patient and clinician. The health
of the permanent successors is somewhat dependant
on the deciduous teeth. As we may say that
deciduous teeth with caries control and well oral
hygiene are a good indicator for the next coming
sound and healthy permanent successors otherwise
in the absence of any systemic disorder that affects
bones and teeth. The main etiologic factor for dental
diseases is the caries or the trauma leading to pulp
exposure. In case of major pulp exposure,
endodontics is indicated as sole treatment option in
conjunction with the evaluation of the affected tooth
prior to going for treatment. The patency of canals
and root morphology is of prime importance while
going for the endodontics. The main aim of this study
is to evaluate and assess the root and canal
morphology of extracted human primary mandibular
and maxillary first molars.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
This prospective in vitro study was carried at Nishtar
Institute of Dentistry Multan from June 2014 to
August 2014. A total number of 60 extracted
deciduous molar teeth were collected without having
any sign of gross root resorption or fracture from the
Department of Pedodontics, Nishtar Institute of
Dentistry Multan. These teeth were meant for this
study to investigate the root canals and morphology
and were collected randomly after being extracted.
The collected teeth were divided into two categories;
category I - mandibular first molars (n=30) and
category II - maxillary first molars (n=30). All the
extracted teeth were cleaned to make them free of
debris and blood clots by washing in running tap
water. Ultrasonic scaler (Piezon, Japan) was used to
remove any hard tissue like bony remnants or the
calculus. All the surfaces were made clean free of
debris. The collected teeth were then placed and
stored at room temperature in a glass containers
filled with distilled water. The number, length and
angulation of the roots were then determined. The
length of the roots was measured after pointing of the
cervical and apical reference point on tracing paper
to the nearest 1 mm using a 6 inch long scale. The
measurement was rounded off to the nearest 1mm.
The most constricted area was considered a cervical
1044 P J M H S Vol. 9, NO. 3, JUL – SEP 2015
3
point and the apex of the root was assumed as an
apical reference point. Coronal root angulation was
evaluated and assessed using a protractor. The
angle was measured between a line perpendicular to
3
the cervical line and then a fabricating a tangent to
the outer surface of the coronal part of each root on
tracing paper. This method had been employed
according to a study that was meant for root canal
morphology of human primary molars3.
As no
clearing technique has been documented for
deciduous teeth, so we modified the technique that
4,5
was meant for permanent teeth. Access cavities
were prepared using a fissure diamond bur (SF 12
Mani Japan) used in air turbine (NSK Japan) for
penetration into the pulp chamber. Then Endo Z bur
(E0152, 21mm Mani Japan) having non-cutting end
was used for de-roofing of all the extracted teeth.
Two things are necessary for the proper finding to be
assed. Firstly, the clean tooth surface and secondly,
the disinfection. For both of these purposes, the teeth
were placed and immersed for 24 hours in 5.25%
sodium hypochlorite solution (Sultan Englewood, NJ
USA). For making teeth decalcified, the teeth were
again immersed in 6% hydrochloric acid (Merck,
Darmstadt, Germany) for 24 hours first, and then
washed under running tap water for one hour to flush
out any debris remnants. After that it was followed by
passage through different concentrations of ethyl
alcohol for dehydration of the teeth. The sequence of
ethyl alcohol concentrations used was 70%, 80%,
90%, and absolute ethanol. The teeth were immersed
in each concentration for 5 hours. Clearing of the
teeth was done by immersing them in a mixed
solution of methyl salicylate and absolute ethanol for
5 hours, followed by immersion in methyl salicylate
(Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) until the next step of
procedure. India ink was injected into the root canals
of the transparent teeth. In case of incomplete
passing of dye into the canals, the suction was
applied at the apical portion of teeth for a thorough
distribution and flow of dye. After injecting the dye,
the roots of the teeth were first examined under a
magnifying glass (Lumagny, No. 7540, Hong Kong)
at
×5 magnification
and then
under
a
stereomicroscope (Olympus, Tokyo, Japan) at X10
magnification for a better vision and thorough
inspection. The canal type according to Vertucci’s
classification, the root canal curvature (straight,
curved or S-shaped) and root canal angulation were
6
determined. Statistical analysis was then applied to
determine the frequency, mean, standard deviation
and range for all two categories using the SPSS-20
version of software.
RESULTS
Sher Muhammad, Rehman Shahid, Muhammad Ismail Siddiqui
All the mandibular molars had two roots i.e., one
mesial and one distal. All the variants pertaining to
the number of root canals, curvature of the canals
and type according to the Vertucci’s has been
mentioned in the table 1a and 1b. The mean length of
the mesial root was found to be 8.99mm and mean
o
angulation was 10.80 . The mean length of the distal
root was 7.10mm and the root angulation that of
8.10o. All the maxillary deciduous molars had three
roots, i.e. mesiobuccal, distobuccal and palatal.
Mostly the teeth had three separate roots. Only a
small fraction i.e., 4(13.33%) had fused palatal and
distobuccal roots. The mesiobuccal root was found to
be the longest root with mean of 8.00 followed by
palatal with mean of 7.54 and distobuccal having
mean of 6.80. There was a small difference in lengths
between the palatal and the distobuccal roots. The
mesiobuccal root showed the maximum mean
angulation of 18.740 followed by distobuccal and
palatal having the mean angulation of 15.410 and
12.490 respectively (Tables 1-4).
Table 1: Deciduous mandibular first molar data
Variants
No.
Root Canal Number
Mesial root
1
3
2
27
Distal root
1
26
2
4
Canal curvatures (mesial root)
MB canal
Straight
9
Curved
18
MI canal
Straight
21
Curved
6
Mesial canal
Straight
2
Curved
1
Canal curvatures (distal root)
DB canal
Straight
3
Curved
1
DL canal
Straight
2
Curved
2
Distal canal
Straight
16
Curved
10
Vertucci’s type of canal
Mesial root
Class IV
27
Class I
3
Distal root
Class IV
4
Class I
26
%
-
-
-
-
Table 2: Mean±SD of mandibular first molar
Variants
Range
Root length
Mesial root
7-10 mm
Distal root
8-10 mm
Root angulation
Mesial root
3-17°
Distal root
3-17°
Table 3: Deciduous maxillary first molar data
Variants
No.
Root Canal Number
MB root
1
24
2
6
DB root
1
25
2
5
Palatal root
1
30
Canal curvatures
MB canal
Straight
4
Curved
26
DB canal
Straight
6
Curved
22
S shaped
2
Palatal canal
Straight
26
Curved
4
Vertucci’s type of canal
MB root
Class IV
6
Class I
24
DB root
Class IV
5
Class I
25
Palatal root
Class I
30
Table 4: Mean±SD of maxillary first molar
Variants
Range
Root length
MB root
8-10 mm
DB root
5-10 mm
Palatal root
5-11 mm
Root angulation
MB root
5-29°
DB root
5-27°
Palatal root
4-29°
Mean±SD-
%-
-
-
Mean±SD-±-±5.39
DISCUSSION
Different studies have been done to get an accurate
root and canal morphology of deciduous teeth. These
studies have used techniques like including
radiography7 computed tomography4 and clearing7
Zoremchhingi et al4 have explored the root and canal
morphology of primary molars in an Indian population
using a CT scan technique. They found that it had
P J M H S Vol. 9, NO. 3, JUL – SEP-
Root and Canal Morphology of Human Primary Molars in a Local Population of Southern Punjab
wide variations having certain complexities also.
CBCT (cone beam computerized tomography) is a
relatively new and effective technology, which
provides a good image to add conventional
radiography for assessing the variation in root canal
14
morphology of primary teeth.
The prevalence of fused palatal and distobuccal
roots in primary maxillary molars was common in
Indians.4 Gupta and Grewal8 and investigated the root
canal configuration of deciduous mandibular first
molars in another Indian community using
radiographic
and
clearing
methods.
Their
investigation showed certain variations in the root
canal morphology of these primary teeth. Their
finding was a maximum of five root canals in a single
specimen, and most of the specimens had four root
8
canals on average.
Pulpotomy is the “partial pulp removal,” a
technique, which has high successful rate of nearly
90%. It is used to treat the accidental, iatrogenic or
carious pulp exposures. When the inflammation or
infection is confined to the coronal area of the pulp,
this technique is much beneficial to the patient. The
procedure includes removal of the coronal portion of
the pulp while at the same time preserving the vitality
of the remaining root areas of the pulp. Pulpectomy is
the procedure that involves complete removal of all
the pulp tissue because of disease or trauma. If a
child has tooth pain along with swelling of the gums
or cheek, this requires the immediate clinician’s
attention. A small hole is made to gain entry in pulp
chamber with the help of high speed air turbine on
the occlusal surface of the tooth. Its purpose is to
drain the abscess or removal of necrotic pulpal tissue
in order to give an immediate soothing effect to the
patient without having any danger of further flare ups.
This will remove all of infected tissue from the root
canal/s completely. Root canal anatomy is the study
of the pulp chamber and root canals through the
sectioning of teeth. Both the pulp chamber and the
roots contain the dental pulp. The smaller branches
which are present laterally are termed as accessory
canals. These are most frequently found near the
root end (apex), but may be encountered anywhere
along the root length. The total number of root canals
per tooth depends on the number of the tooth roots
present ranging from one to four, five or sometimes
more in some cases. However sometimes there may
be more than one root canal per root. Some teeth
have a more variable internal anatomy than others.
An unusual root canal shape, complex branching
(especially the existence of horizontal branches), and
multiple root canals are thought to be the main
causes of root canal treatment failures. Tissue debris
or biofilm remnants along such un-instrumented
canal ways may lead to failure due to both
inadequate disinfection, preparation of the canal and
1046 P J M H S Vol. 9, NO. 3, JUL – SEP 2015
the inability to properly obturate the root-canal
space.4 Alternatively, the biofilm should always be
removed with a proper disinfectant during root canal
treatment. Therefore the main goal of the root canal
is to make canals free of the microorganisms and the
infected tissue9,10. The retention of the healthy
primary dentition is a good indicator for proper
3,9,11
phonetics, spacing, mastication and esthetics
.
There are so many methods that may have been
employed for the improvement of our knowledge
regarding to the deciduous root morphology, canal
configuration and investigation of various anomalies
in the canals and roots. Unfortunately no method is
currently devoid of some sort of demerits and
limitations. These methods including the conventional
radiography, computed tomography and filling the
canals with certain materials to investigate the canals
are being employed exclusively. The conventional
periapical radiography is a two dimensional imaging
of the tooth. That’s why the buccolingual root
dimension still needs to be marked on the sample
while in oral cavity the cone shift technique may be
used to differentiate the buccal and lingual roots. The
computed tomography is an excellent option for the
different segments evaluation of the tooth in different
planes but is an expensive one and requires special
operatory training. In our study we have used the
clearing technique which is inexpensive and reliable.
Also there is minimal loss of the enamel.
Most of the teeth in the mandibular first molar
had two roots and two canals (90%) in the mesial
root and one canal in the distal root (86.66%). This is
in accordance to the studies conducted by Gupta and
Grewal8 regarding the canal curvatures, 66.66% of
the canals of the mesiobuccal side were curved while
the ratio being lower in the mesiolingual canal being
22.22%. Although the roots of mesial portion were
fused yet the canals were completely separated. All
the canals in the mandibular molars followed the
straight or the curved pattern. most of the canals in
the distal roots were straight (61.53%). There was a
broader distal canal which was much prominent in
the pulp chamber. The distal root was longer as
compared to the mesial roots. Since the curvatures in
the canals may lead to perforations, zipping, elbow
formation and ledge formation, a good knowledge of
canal morphology and the root structure may provide
12
us convenience to avoid these problems. The
maxillary molars had three canals with slight
discrepancy of 20% and 16.66% with having two
canals in the mesiobuccal and distobuccal canals
respectively. Another finding was the canal curvature
of S shaped in the distobuccal canal. 86.66% canals
of the palatal roots were straight. The palatal roots
found to be the longest roots having 5-11mm of
length. both the palatal roots and distal root length of
Sher Muhammad, Rehman Shahid, Muhammad Ismail Siddiqui
the mandibular were more and in accordance with
3
the Zoremchhingi et al. The study so far done is also
a good source for the morphology of second
deciduous molars because the study of certain
researchers say that external and internal anatomy of
primary first molars are in close resemblance to that
13
of primary second molars.
4.
5.
6.
CONCLUSION
There has been a little evidence of variation in the
root lengths of mandibular molars between mesial
and distal roots, the distal root being longer than
mesial ones. All the orifice openings are rounded or
oval in shape without any band like shape. Palatal
root canals are found to be longest as compared to
mesiobuccal and distobuccal canals. It is common to
have separated root canals even in fused canals.
Most of the distobuccal and palatal canals were
separated. The obtained data in our study may help
clinicians improve sagacity to get a confident
knowledge of the morphological variations of root
canals in primary molars and to overcome problems
related to cleaning, shaping and canal preparation
during root canal procedures, and thus giving a
helping opportunity for the management strategies for
root canal treatment to perform in a better way.
Further research in this respect may reticulate our
clinical experience and broaden our knowledge. A
good knowledge regarding the canal morphology,
being a quintessential requirement may thus improve
the outcomes of root canal preparation and
endodontics.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
Al Hamdani M. Wenzel M. The worm in the tooth.
Folklore 1966;77:60-64.
Roud S. Penguin guide to the superstitions of Britain
and Ireland. London: Penguin 2006.
Zoremchhingi, Joseph T, Varma B, Mungara J. A study
of root canal morphology of human primary molars
14.
using computerized tomography: an in vitro study. J
Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent 2005;23:7-12.
Vatanpour M, Javidi M. Evaluation of different clearing
techniques: an auxiliary method for studying root canal
anatomy. J Islamic Dent Assoc Iran 2997;19: 28-33.
Robertson D, Leeb IJ, Mckee M, Brewer E. A clearing
technique for the study of root canal systems. J Endod
1980;6:421-4.
Cleghorn BM, Christie WH, Dong CC. Root and root
canal morphology of the human permanent maxillary
first molar: a literature review. J Endod 2006; 32: 81321.
Omer OE, Al Shalabi RM, Jennings M, Glennon J,
Claffey NM. A comparison between clearing and
radiographic techniques in the study of root-canal
anatomy of maxillary first and second molars. Int
Endod J 2004; 37: 291-6.
Gupta D, Grewal N. Root canal configuration of
deciduous mandibular first molars - an in vitro study. J
Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent 2005;23:134-7.
Fuks AB. Pulp therapy for primary dentition. In:
Pinkham JR, Casamassimo PS, McTigue DJ, Fields
HW, Nowak AJ, eds. Pediatric dentistry: infancy
through adolescence. 4th ed. Elsevier Saunders, St
Louis, 2005; 375-93.
Guelmann M, McEachern M, Turner C. Pulpectomies
in primary incisors using three delivery systems: an in
vitro study. J Clin Pediatr Dent 2004;28:323-6.
Kandaswamy D, Venkateshbabu N. Root canal
irrigants. J Conserv Dent 2010;13(4):256-64.
Vertucci FJ, Haddix JE, Britto LR. Tooth morphology
and access cavity preparation. In: Cohen S,
Hargreaves KM, Keiser K, eds, Pathways of the pulp,
9th ed. St. Louis: Mosby 2006; 148-232.
Fumes AC, Sousa-Neto MD, Leoni GB, Versiani MA,
da Silva LA, da Silva RA, Consolaro A. Root canal
morphology of primary molars: a micro-computed
tomography study. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent
2014;15(5):317-26.
Gaurav V, Srivastava N, Rana V, Adlakha VK A study
of root canal morphology of human primary incisors
and molars using cone beam computerized
tomography: an in vitro study. J Indian Soc Pedod
Prev Dent 2013;31(4):254-9.
P J M H S Vol. 9, NO. 3, JUL – SEP-