Ramadhani Prasetyo

When Robo-Advisors Know More About Gold Investing Than Humans Figure 1. Gold Investing with Robo Advisors (Hayes, Smith and Velasques, 2024) Introduction Gold is one of the oldest metals used by humans. Since ancient times to exchange, a symbol of economic status, and social status in society (Surjoko, 2013). Gold has been looked for after for its special mix of close indestructibility, magnificence, irregularity because of its status as a implies of trade and widespread cash standard fabulousness for centuries (O’Byrne, 2012). In the modern era, gold proceeds to play a basic part within the worldwide budgetary framework, serving as a support against swelling, a secure resource, and a save resource for central banks (Alimukhamedov, 2024). Robo-Advisors is an online service that use computer algorithms to provide financial advice and manages a customer’s investment portfolio (Fisch, Labouré and Turner, 2015). Robo-Advisors are basically created and you can choose your investment decision choice based on your data and algorithms so you can choose the best decision (Murthi and Anastasia, 2023). This helps you safely especially those starting capital markets. Who Understand Gold Better — Humans or Machine? The rapid development of AI technologies and Robo-advisors in finance today means the profound transformation of asset management: Automatic learning algorithm, natural language treatment and optimization of automatic investment portfolio can analyse large financial data in real time, provide personal investment advice without human need Service and service cost up to 50%, which makes these platforms alternatives and the backbone of modern, comprehensive and very effective Fintech bones (Sabir et al., 2023). In this context, gold becomes a convincing part in automatic investment because, beyond the ability to recover well for inflation and economic fluctuations, advanced algorithm—such as Extreme Learning Machine (ELM)—have proven the ability to predict gold price in gold. Impressive accuracy (a MAPE only 0.29%) allows Robo manufactures to 1 make buy/sell decisions based on real-time data, without human emotional bias—an important advantage in automatic management of the portfolio (Wati, Cholissodin and Adikara, 2019). If machines can now learn market patterns, analysing thousands of economic variable within seconds, and making investment decision objectively without being influenced by emotions such as fear or greed, then the important question arises that deserves serious thought: is human instinct, which has long been seen as the main compass in financial decision-making, still relevant in an age when algorithms can act faster and more accurately using real-time data that no human could ever fully process? How Robo-Advisors Work in Gold Investment Robo-Advisors run through a systematic and transparent working process, starting with the contribution of data in which customer information such as risk record, investments goals and financial situation are collected. Next is to treat with algorithms with quantities methods, from the optimization of the average variance, of automatic learning to enhance learning to create a suitable portfolio. The system then made recommendations to automatically distribute and balance property strategies. And finally, the implementation is automatically or semiautomatic, making sure the portfolio is adapted to the market dynamics continuously and without humans emotional intervention (Beketov, Lehmann and Wittke, 2018). When investing in gold, algorithms are helpful. They can go through tons of past data like price changes, how volatile the market is, and even big-picture economic signals to spot trends that most people might miss (Cohen, 2022). Also, they look at each investor’s personal info, like goals, risk comfort, and background, to come up with gold investment plans that make sense for them (So, 2021). And since it’s all done automatically, it avoids the emotional ups and downs that usually affect human investors. Figure 2. Gold Price Chart- (Goldprice, 2025) Beat Robo-Advisor stages like Betterment and Wealthfront offer gold assignment choices with gold-based ETF such as GLD. While, StashAway combines valuable metals into its Financial Regime-Based Resource Allotment system in upgrade portfolio solidness and execution. Illustrating that advanced Robo-Advisor has advanced past fair values and bonds to deliberately incorporate commodities like gold for expansion and instability security. In contrast to Robo-Advisors which operate automatically using algorithms to manage portfolios swiftly at low cost with automatic rebalancing, a human financial advisor provides 2 a more personalized and holistic service by understanding the client’s entire financial situation including tax, estate planning, and offering emotional support and deeper understanding of complex life changes, thus able to adjust investment strategies based on each individual’s unique context (Hayes, Smith and Velasques, 2024). Robo-Advisor Advantages in Gold Analysis Compared to Ordinary Investors In gold investment analysis, Robo-Advisors provide distinct advantages as they can make datadriven decisions by processing thousands of market indicators in real time, remain unaffected by emotions such as fear of missing out or panic selling, perform automatic rebalancing so the portfolio adjusts immediately in response to rises or falls in gold prices, and even tailor investment strategies according to investor goals such as short-term needs, retirement planning, or hedging against inflation (Chloe, 2024). Aspect Robo-Advisor Ordinary Investor Analyses thousands of realRelies on limited data sources and Decision-Making time market indicators personal interpretation instantly Often influenced by market Free from emotional influences Emotional Bias sentiment, fear, and impulsive like FOMO or panic selling decisions Automatically rebalances Rebalancing Manual rebalancing that may be portfolio based on gold price Capability delayed or inconsistent movements Automatically adjusts to fit Requires active effort and Strategy investor goals (short-term, discipline to align strategy with Adjustment retirement, inflation hedge, evolving goals etc.) Market 24/7 continuous tracking and Limited by individual attention Monitoring response to price changes span, time, and expertise Integrated with May lack access to or Access to Global macroeconomic, geopolitical, understanding of complex market Indicators and historical data for gold indicators analysis Potentially higher costs if using Cost and Low-cost service with minimal financial advisors or making Efficiency human involvement frequent manual trades Maintains consistent logic and Can be inconsistent depending on Consistency discipline across all market mood, news cycles, or peer conditions influence Easily manages multiple users Limited to individual capacity and Scalability and large portfolios time simultaneously Transparency Offers clear algorithm-based Decision-making may be unclear or decision logic (on many undocumented platforms) Table 1. Robo-Advisor Advantages Compared to Ordinary Investors (Hasanudin, 2025) 3 Case Study Example: Comparing 3 Major Investment Methods Self RoboAdvisor Financial Advisor Annual Fees Stock Picking Tax/Estate Tax-Loss Rebalancing Planning Harvesting 0% ? X X X Varies wildly 0.25% X X ? ? Low 1% X ? ? ? Varies Risk Table 2. Comparison 3 Major Investment Methods (Smith, 2024) Comparison of 3 main investment methods: self-management, Robo-Advisor and financial advisor. Autonomous investment has no annual fees (0%), providing high flexibility, including the ability to choose your own action, but requires knowledge and risks that are different. Robo advisers provide an automatic approach at a low cost (about 0.25%), do not allow the choice of individual stocks, but provide adaptation to your risk records and often have lower risks. Meanwhile, financial advisors calculate the highest cost (about 1%) because they provide personal services such as stock selection, tax planning or inheritance and portfolio management, with the level of risk according to the quality of advice provided (Smith, 2024). How did the Singapore Robo-Advisors Portfolio perform over 2.5 years with XIRR? Figure 3. XIRR chart of each Robo-Advisor portfolio (Kyith, 2023) Each point on this chart measures the XIRR of the portfolio at a specific point. For case, if the XIRR plotted for Syfe Value 100 on the 6th of Feb is 14.78%, it infers from the begin of 20th July 2020 to 6th Feb 2021, the” the interest rate earned” is an annualized 14.78%. It too implies on the off chance you offer on 6th Feb 2021 you’ll win net-net 14.78% a year return. Hence, each point on the chart appears the annualized returns if you offer it (Kyith, 2023). 4 The Future of Gold Investment: Humans and Machines Walking Together? The developing trend of hybrid investing brings together productivity and personalization as the Robo-Advisor fastidiously oversees schedule assignments like portfolio allotment and programmed rebalancing using calculations, but the human advisor contributes by building connections, giving enthusiastic bolster, and tending to complex money related arranging such as tax contemplations or domain arranging, empowering financial specialists to advantage ideally from both approaches (Petro, Babych and Kardash, 2021). Advances in AI will make market sentiment and automatic interpretation of global news increasingly possible as voice models such as Transformers-based NLP systems and Finbert and Large Language Models can recognize subtle moods in millions of news article and social media. This data contributed and integrated into an automated investment framework to predict market movements with high accuracy and quickly show the risks and opportunities of human investors for most (Kirtac and Germano, 2024). Over the next five to ten years, we expect that personal financing will become increasingly automated by assigning assets, dynamic balance and real-time financial data processing using intelligent algorithms. Review of goals, results, and consideration of complex ethical and situational factors that let investors benefit from technical efficiency without losing personal control or trust (Sofea, 2024). Conclusions According to all advanced technologies, Robo-Advisors are tools and not substitutes for your own understanding. Machines can scan market data in seconds and provide investment advice that sounds intelligent and logical. But do you know when you want to buy a house? Or do you understand that you can focus on your child’s training before maximizing your returns? The human elements are still important here. Technology can lead, but they are still the ones who hold the cards. Ideally, you will learn the basics of gold investment while gradually using intelligent tools such as Robo-Advisors. So, your financial decisions are based not only on numbers and performance diagrams, but also on long-term goals and personal. Reference Alimukhamedov, K. (2024) Gold Investing Handbook for Asset Managers, The World Bank. Washington: www.worldbank.org. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1596/dspace/60478. Beketov, M., Lehmann, K. and Wittke, M. (2018) “Robo Advisors: quantitative methods inside the robots,” Journal of Asset Management, 19(6), pp. 363–370. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1057/s-. Chloe (2024) Optimizing Finances with Robo-Advisors: Automatic Rebalancing and Risk Management, momentslog. Available at: https://www.momentslog.com/investment/optimizing-finances-with-roboadvisors-automatic-rebalancing-and-risk-management (Accessed: June 21, 2025). Cohen, https://www. momentslog. com/investment/optimizing-finances-with-robo-advisorsautomatic-rebalancing-and-risk-managemen. G. (2022) Algorithmic Strategies for Precious Metals Price Forecasting, Mathematics. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/math-. Fisch, J.E., Labouré, M. and Turner, J.A. (2015) “Securing Future Retirements: Innovations in Planning Strategies, Financial Products and Employee Benefit Plan Structure Automated Advice,” researchgate, pp. 1–6. Available at: https://www.consumerreports.org/personal-investing/rise-. 5 Goldprice (2025) Spot Gold Price Charts, goldprice.org. Available at: https://goldprice.org/spot-gold.html (Accessed: June 22, 2025). Hasanudin (2025) “The Impact of Robo-Advisors and Risk Tolerance on Retail Investor Portfolio Performance,” Journal of Ecohumanism, 4(1), pp-. Available at: https://doi.org/-/joe.v4i1.5977. Hayes, A., Smith, A. and Velasques, V. (2024) Are Robo-Advisors Worth It?, Investopedia. Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/are-robo-advisors-worth-it- (Accessed: June 21, 2025). Kirtac, K. and Germano, G. (2024) “Sentiment trading with large language models,” Finance Research Letters, 62(PB), p. 105227. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl-. Kyith (2023) Membandingkan Kinerja Portofolio Beberapa Robo Advisor Singapura (Pembaruan 2023 2,4 Tahun Kemudian). Apakah MoneyOwl Terus Berkinerja Baik?, investmentmoats. Available at: https://investmentmoats.com/money/comparing-performance-singapore-roboadvisers-2023-update/ (Accessed: June 22, 2025). Murthi, A.T. and Anastasia, N. (2023) “Pengaruh Perilaku Bias Terhadap Keputusan Investasi Oleh Investor Dengan Moderasi Robo-Advisor,” Manajemen Dewantara [Preprint]. Available at: https://geldanlage-digital.de/robo-advisor/vorteile/. O’Byrne, M. (2012) A Beginner’s Guide to Investing in Gold, GoldCore. Available at: http://scioteca.caf.com/bitstream/handle/-/1091/RED2017-Eng8ene.pdf?sequence=12&isAllowed=y%0Ahttp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.regsciurbeco -%0Ahttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/-_SISTEM_ PEMBETUNGAN_TERPUSAT_STRATEGI_MELESTARI. Petro, H., Babych, T. and Kardash, O. (2021) “Management of investment hybrid portfolio,” (January). Available at: https://doi.org/10.1504/IJBPM-. Sabir, A.A. et al. (2023) “Consumer Acceptance and Adoption of AI Robo-Advisors in Fintech Industry,” Mathematics, 11(6), pp. 1–24. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/math-. Smith, C. (2024) Investing: Self-Directed vs. Robo-Advisor vs. Financial Advisor, clark. Available at: https://clark.com/personal-finance-credit/investing-retirement/selfdirected-vs-robo-advisor-vs-financial-advisor/ (Accessed: June 21, 2025). So, M.K.P. (2021) “Robo-advising risk profiling through content analysis for sustainable development in the Hong Kong financial market,” Sustainability (Switzerland), 13(3), pp. 1–15. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/su-. Sofea, A. (2024) “THE FUTURE OF MONEY MANAGEMENT HARNESSING ARTIFICIAL THE FUTURE OF MONEY MANAGEMENT HARNESSING ARTIFICIAL Anees Sofea Binti Mohd Fauzi School of Economics , Finance and Banking , Universiti Utara Malaysia-,” (July), pp. 0–14. Available at: https://doi.org/-/RG-. Surjoko, F. (2013) “Pandangan Investor Terhadap Emas Sebagai Investasi Sejak 2012,” Bina Ekonomi, 17(2), pp. 1–8. Wati, L.R.S., Cholissodin, I. and Adikara, P.P. (2019) “Implementasi Algoritme Extreme Learning Machine (ELM) Untuk Prediksi Harga Emas Bagi Investor,” Jurnal Pengembangan Teknologi Informasi dan Ilmu Komputer, 3(3), pp-. Available at: http://j-ptiik.ub.ac.id. 6