Fictional Reading and Intelligence (Case Study type article)
Does Reading Fiction Affect Intelligence?
Fiction reveals truths that reality obscures.
We may think that reading non-fiction rather than fiction books makes us
more intelligent. It is because non-fiction books present factual and actual
information rather than fiction which is not based on facts or true events and
is based on an imaginary setting. As we grow older, we are slowly being
weaned off of fiction books. Our school alone requires us more nonfictional
reading since it comprises majority of our learning materials. However,
research shows that reading fiction actually makes us smarter. Aside from
improving our vocabulary and language skills, it also helps us stay sharp.
Reading fiction also boosts emotional intelligence as we learn to put
ourselves in someone else’s shoes and empathize with the characters in
what we are reading.
The Case of Sam: Reading Fiction and its Impact on Intelligence
A case study conducted by Gregory Cost documented the impact of reading
fiction on one’s intelligence. The participant was a 10-year old boy who is an
avid reader of fiction, at the elementary level and is immersed in the
Common Core curriculum. He loves beach reading fiction on a regular basis.
The study is focused on exploring the role of fiction in literacy experience
and learning.
Three methods were employed to collect necessary data in this study. First,
the Fountas and Pinnell Reading Interview was conducted at the beginning
and are designed to identify feelings, interests, and motivations regarding
reading. Next, the Benchmark Assessment System was used to inform
understanding of Sam’s literacy achievement. It was administered in the
form of a running record, coupled with comprehension checks and prompts.
Lastly, anecdotal notes were conducted every meeting for record purposes
only.
As a result of the study, the impact of reading fiction to one’s literacy
experience is that it aids in text comprehension and it is also engaging.
Reading fiction aids a person in text comprehension as it helps us sequence
plot, identify main ideas, and provide empathetic solutions to textual
problems. It is also engaging since fictional reading can be done for pleasure
purposes as it serves as a way to escape and have some time alone.
It was also discovered that reading fiction had influenced the child in three
particular ways: fiction can be used to teach lessons and morals, fiction is
read for pleasure, and fiction is used to aid story sequencing and
comprehension.
Based on the study, it could be implied that it would be better if fictional
reading is coupled with the curriculum since it can help students in their
literacy experiences as well as their intelligence.
Another
research
shows
that
popular
fiction
depicts
extraordinary
circumstances and takes readers on a mix of emotions and exciting
experiences.
Despite
the
fact
that
settings
and
circumstances
are
unbelievably unique, there is a consistency and predictability in characters
which affirms the reader’s expectations of others. It implies that popular
fiction does not expand a reader’s empathy.
In contrast with popular fiction, literary fiction is focused on the psychology
of characters and their connection to each other. These characters thoughts
are portrayed ambiguously and we are compelled to fill in the gaps to
comprehend their expectations and inspirations. Although literary fiction has
a tendency to be more rational than popular fiction, the characters interrupt
a reader’s expectations and stereotypes which teach us the significance of
understanding those individuals who are different from us.
Non-fiction Literature and Its Influence on Intelligence
Reading works of fiction influences intelligence in different ways but does it
mean that reading non-fiction has a negative impact on our intelligence?
A study was conducted to compare how reading fiction and non-fiction
literatures affect a person’s overall intelligence. Participants were distributed
across two subscales. One is for an assessment of exposure to narrative
fiction. Participants were also distributed into five genres. Another is for the
measure of exposure to non-narrative expository nonfiction which is also
divided into five genres. Results show that exposure to non-fiction literature
was negatively related to self-perceived belongingness. Non-fiction was also
related to self-reported loneliness in contrast to those exposed to fiction.
Another study showed that nonfiction literature does not improve a person’s
ability to understand other’s mental states. Reading fictional literature led to
better ability on both emotional and cognitive function compared with those
who read non-fiction works. Those who read nonfiction had low scores on
empathy compared to those who read fiction which implies that exposure to
fictional works have a great influence our emotional intelligence and help us
understand other’s thoughts and feelings.
Summing It Up
In general, reading greatly affects our brain. May it be fiction or non-fiction,
as long as we spend time for reading, we can experience the fascinating
effects and benefits of it. Reading makes our brain grow. Since it improves
our vocabulary, it makes our brain grow as more connections are made.
Reading can also make us feel encounters or experiences on what we read
as our own. It is like living on someone else’s shoes.
Reading can also be an effective stress reliever due to escapism. When we
are focused on a book, we are less focused on our tense muscles and we
relax.
We also genuinely feel the metaphors that we read. Reading fiction has
always been good in broadening one’s outlook and it also makes us more
empathetic.
Reading intricate characters also prompts the brain to write them in order to
interpret and remember it well. It is as if our brain is physically moving a
pen over the lines of the symbol.
Reading, especially poetry, also boosts our memory the same way music
does. It links to the right half of the brain, which regulates emotion.
It makes us prone to be sent into a self-reflective, memory-boosting state,
particularly when reading well-known poems we love. Poetry also lights up
the areas of the brain that concern memory and switch on when we're
relaxing. We call it the poetry trance.
Due to a lot of general positive effects of reading to us, we should realize
how necessary it is to be a regular part of our daily life. Don’t be a book
snob. Relax and grab a book and drift away to places you can only read
about.