IMPACT OF VOCATIONAL EDUCATION ON YOUTH UNEMPLOYMENT IN GWALE LOCAL GOVERNMENT, KANO STATE
BY
S/N
NAME
REGISTRATION NO.
1.
SALMA ABDULRAHMAN YUSHA
U21FV2089
2.
HAUWAU ISMAIL UMAR
U21FV2095
3.
AMINA MURTALA SALIM
U21FV2067
BEING A RESEARCH WORK SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL BUSINESS EDUCATION, FACULTY OF VOCATIONAL EDUCATION, YUSUF MAITAMA SULE FEDERAL UNIVERSITY KANO, NIGERIA. IN PARTIAL FUFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF B.ED BUSINESS EDUCATION.
SUPERVISOR:
MARY INALEGWU
APRIL, 2025
DECLARATION
We hereby declare that this work is the product of my own research effort, undertaken under the supervision of Mary Inalegwu. All sources have been duly acknowledged.
________________________________________________
SALMA ABDULRAHMAN YUSHADATE
U21FV2089
________________________________________________
HAUWAU ISMAIL UMARDATE
U21FV2095
________________________________________________
AMINA MURTALA SALIMDATE
U21FV2067
APPROVAL PAGE
This research project entitled “Impact of Vocational Education on Youth Unemployment in Gwale Local Government, Kano State”, has been read and approved as meeting the regulation governing the award of B.Ed. Business Education.
------------------------------------- -----------------------------
MARY INALEGWU DATE
(SUPERVISOR)
------------------------------------- ------------------------------
DR. SYLVESTER UGBEDATE
(H.O.D)
------------------------------------- -----------------------------
EXTERNAL EXAMINERDATE
DEDICATION
We dedicated this research work to our parents.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Surely all praise is due to Allah (S.W.A) Who endowed men and women with well-developed mental faculties, spiritual of inspiration as well as power of actions. The Beneficent, the Merciful, the Greatest, the Highest, may His peace and blessings be upon the Holy Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) Amin.
We are very grateful to Almighty Allah who granted me the opportunity, the good health and preserving lecturers, that enable me to pass through the memorable period of the course successfully. We hereby specially thanks and acknowledge with gratitude and respect, the guidance, encouragement and contributions given to us by supervisor in person of Mary Inalegwu, who spared her time despite her tight engagements and attended to us in more ways than one throughout the period of our research work. May Allah reward her abundantly and continue to help her in all her affairs, Ameen.
We also acknowledge the motivation and contribution we got from all of our lecturers and the entire academic and none academic staffs of the Department of Business Education, may Allah reward them.
Moreover, we cannot conclude without thanking our great and unforgettable friends and colleagues who immensely contribute towards the success of our studies in one way or the other in the Department of Business Education, Yusuf Maitama Sule Federal University Kano.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents
DECLARATIONii
APPROVAL PAGEiii
DEDICATIONiv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSv
TABLE OF CONTENTSvi
ABSTRACTviii
CHAPTER ONE1
INTRODUCTION1
1.1 Background of the Study1
1.2 Statement of the Problem4
1.3 Objectives of the Study5
1.4 Research Questions5
1.5 Significance of the Study6
1.6 Scope /Delimitation of the Study7
1.7 Definitions of Terms7
CHAPTER TWO9
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE9
2.1 Concept of Vocational Education9
2.2 Concept of Unemployment10
2.3 Impact of Vocational Education Among Youths in Gwale LGA of Kano State12
2.4 Impact of Unemployment Among Youths in Gwale Local Government Gwale LGA of Kano State13
2.5 Challenges Faced by Youths in Accessing Vocational Education in Gwale LGA.15
2.6 Summary of Literature Review17
CHAPTER THREE20
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY20
3.1 Research Design20
3.2 Population of the Study21
3.3 Sample Size and Sampling Technique21
3.4 Instrument for Data Collection22
3.5 Validity of the Instrument22
3.6 Reliability of the Instrument23
3.7 Procedure for Data Collection23
3.8 Procedure for Data Analysis23
CHAPTER FOUR24
DATA PRESENTATION, AND ANALYSIS24
4.1 Demographic Data of the Respondents24
4.2 Research Questions26
4.3 Summary of Major Findings30
4.4 Discussions of Findings31
CHAPTER FIVE33
SUMMAR, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS33
5.1 Summary33
5.2 Conclusion33
5.3 Recommendations34
REFERENCES35
APPENDIX37
ABSTRACT
This study examines the effectiveness of vocational education programs in addressing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government Area, Kano State, Nigeria. A mixed-methods research design was employed, incorporating both quantitative and qualitative approaches to gather data from 346 respondents across various demographic groups. The study identified youth unemployment as a severe and pressing issue, primarily driven by structural challenges such as limited access to quality education, economic stagnation, and a mismatch between acquired skills and labor market demands. Findings revealed that although vocational education programs are available and generally successful in equipping youth with practical skills and entrepreneurial mindsets, their impact is significantly hindered by poor infrastructure, high training costs, and lack of alignment with local industry needs. Cultural factors were not seen as major barriers to vocational training participation, indicating a positive community perception of such programs. The study concludes that while vocational education has potential as a tool for reducing youth unemployment, systemic challenges limit its full effectiveness. Recommendations include enhancing accessibility through government support, aligning training with market needs, strengthening post-training support, increasing awareness among underrepresented groups, and conducting further research to evaluate long-term outcomes.
Keywords: Vocational education, youth unemployment, skill acquisition, Gwale Local Government, Kano State, Nigeria.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of the Study
Youth unemployment is one of the most critical challenges facing Nigeria today, particularly given its rapidly growing youthful population. With more than half of Nigeria's population under the age of 35, the demand for employment opportunities far exceeds the available supply. This mismatch has created a significant strain on the country’s labour market, leaving many young people unable to find jobs. As the youth demographic continues to expand, Nigeria has struggled to create adequate job opportunities to meet their needs, exacerbating the unemployment crisis. This issue is further complicated by the slow growth of industries and sectors that could absorb this rising workforce, leading to a more entrenched unemployment problem.
Recent statistics from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) highlight the severity of the situation. In 2023, the unemployment rate among young individuals aged 15-34 surged to 42.5%, marking a substantial increase from previous years (NBS, 2023). This alarming figure reflects not only the scale of the problem but also the growing urgency for solutions. The high unemployment rate among youth presents a myriad of challenges for Nigeria, ranging from economic instability to rising crime rates, as many young people turn to informal or illicit activities in the absence of formal employment. in region like Gwale LGA of Kano State, where youth unemployment has reached critical levels. In areas such as Gwale, the lack of job opportunities has contributed to a variety of socio-economic problems. Unemployment fuels poverty, as families struggle to support themselves without a steady income. It also leads to social unrest, as frustrated youths involve in criminal activities or political violence. Additionally, the underdevelopment of local economies, driven by high unemployment, further hampers any efforts to improve living standards or stimulate growth. The cycle of unemployment and underdevelopment becomes difficult to break, trapping many communities in a state of persistent poverty.
Addressing youths unemployment in Nigeria, particularly in regions like Gwale, requires tailored interventions that focus on the root causes of the problem. These interventions must not only provide immediate job opportunities but also create sustainable pathways for employment in the future. Strategies such as vocational education, entrepreneurship development, and skills training have been proposed as viable solutions to equip young people with the skills needed to compete in the labour market. Moreover, these efforts must be accompanied by policies that support industrial growth and job creation in order to absorb the growing youths population. Without these critical interventions, the cycle of unemployment and its associated challenges will continue to undermine Nigeria's economic and social stability.
Vocational education has increasingly gained recognition as a crucial strategy to address youth unemployment in Nigeria. Unlike general education, which provides a broad base of knowledge, vocational education focuses on equipping individuals with specific, job-related skills that are directly applicable to the labour market. This form of education emphasizes hands-on training in trades, crafts, and technical careers, making graduates more readily employable in various industries. According to research, vocational education can significantly enhance the employability of young people by aligning their skills with the practical demands of the workforce (Emeh, 2019). In a developing economy like Nigeria, where formal employment opportunities are limited, vocational education plays a vital role in fostering self-employment and entrepreneurship. This shift from reliance on traditional job markets to creating one's own opportunities is essential for reducing unemployment, especially in regions with high youths population.
Despite its recognized potential, the implementation of vocational education in Nigeria remains uneven and is hindered by numerous challenges. Many vocational programs, particularly in regions like Gwale Local Government, suffer from insufficient funding and poor management. Inadequate infrastructure and outdated training materials often leave students ill-prepared for the realities of the modern labour market. Furthermore, these programs frequently lack proper alignment with the needs of employers, resulting in a gap between the skills taught and those that are actually in demand (Adebisi & Oni, 2021). This disconnect means that even those who complete vocational training may struggle to find employment, as the training they receive does not match industry requirements.
Additionally, socio-cultural factors present significant barriers to the success of vocational education. There is often a societal preference for formal, academic education, with vocational careers seen as less prestigious. This stigma surrounding vocational training discourages many young people from enrolling, despite its potential to offer more immediate employment opportunities. The societal pressure to pursue academic education often leaves vocational training underutilized and undervalued, contributing to the continued high levels of youth unemployment (Adeola & Fayomi, 2019). These challenges highlight the need for policy reforms and social awareness campaigns to improve the perception and effectiveness of vocational education as a solution to youths unemployment in Nigeria.
Youths unemployment in Gwale Local Government is particularly acute, largely due to the area's enduring socio-economic challenges. High levels of poverty, limited access to quality education, and a scarcity of employment opportunities have created an environment where young people struggle to find meaningful work. As a result, many youths in the region are trapped in cycles of poverty and social instability, contributing to wider socio-economic issues. Over time, various vocational education initiatives have been introduced in Gwale to help equip young people with practical skills that can increase their chances of finding employment or starting their own businesses. These programs aim to address the gap between formal education and the labour market by providing skills tailored to specific industries.
Despite these efforts, the effectiveness of vocational education programs in reducing youth unemployment in Gwale has not been thoroughly assessed. There is limited understanding of how accessible these programs are to the local youth, whether they are aligned with the needs of the job market, or how successful they have been in helping participants secure employment. This study seeks to fill that gap by examining the availability, accessibility, and effectiveness of vocational training programs in the area. By evaluating these factors, the research will provide critical insights that can guide policymakers and program managers in making informed decisions about how to improve vocational education. Ultimately, the goal is to enhance the impact of these programs in reducing youth unemployment, thereby contributing to the socio-economic development of Gwale Local Government.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Despite the increasing recognition of vocational education as a vital tool for addressing youth unemployment in Nigeria, the problem remains pervasive, particularly in regions like Gwale Local Government, Gwale LGA of Kano State. Youth unemployment in Gwale is not only a socio-economic challenge but also a potential catalyst for broader social instability, given that a large proportion of the population are youths without sustainable employment. The Nigerian government, through various initiatives, has sought to promote vocational education as a means to empower young people with practical skills that can lead to self-employment or make them more competitive in the job market. However, the effectiveness of these vocational programs in Gwale has not been comprehensively evaluated.
One of the primary issues is the apparent mismatch between the vocational training provided and the actual demands of the labour market in Gwale. Many young people who complete vocational programs still find it difficult to secure employment or start their own businesses due to a lack of relevant skills, inadequate access to resources, and limited support systems. Additionally, there are significant challenges facing vocational education in the region, such as insufficient infrastructure, inadequate funding, and social perceptions that undervalue vocational careers in favor of formal education. These factors contribute to the persistence of youth unemployment, despite the existence of vocational education programs. This research, therefore, seeks to investigate the impact of vocational education on youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government area of Gwale LGA of Kano State, Nigeria. It aims to identify the specific challenges that hinder the effectiveness of vocational training programs and to assess how well these programs are aligned with the needs of the local economy. The study will also explore the experiences of youths in accessing vocational education and their subsequent employment outcomes, providing insights into the gaps that need to be addressed to make vocational education an effective tool for reducing youth unemployment in the region.
1.3 Objectives of the Study
The following research objectives were formulated to guide this study: The main objective of this study is to assess the impact of vocational education in reducing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government, Gwale LGA of Kano State. Specifically the study seek to:
1. To assess the current state of youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government.
2. To assess the availability and types of vocational education programs in Gwale Local Government.
3. To examine the effectiveness of vocational education programs in reducing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government.
1.4 Research Questions
The following research questions are poised to give answers to the formulated objectives:
1. What is the current rate of youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government, and what factors contribute to it?
2. To what extent vocational education program is available to youths in Gwale Local Government Area?
3. What is the effectiveness of vocational education programs in reducing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government?
1.5 Significance of the Study
This study is significant in several ways, particularly in its potential to contribute to both academic knowledge and practical policy-making regarding youth unemployment and vocational education in Nigeria, specifically within Gwale Local Government, Gwale LGA of Kano State.
Firstly, the study addresses a critical socio-economic issue: youth unemployment. By focusing on the impact of vocational education, the research provides insights into one of the most viable solutions for reducing unemployment among young people. In a country like Nigeria, where formal employment opportunities are limited, vocational education offers an alternative pathway to economic self-sufficiency through the acquisition of practical skills. The findings of this study could therefore highlight the importance of vocational training as a strategic tool for national development, particularly in regions with high unemployment rates.
Secondly, the study will provide valuable information for policymakers, educators, and development practitioners. By evaluating the effectiveness of current vocational education programs in Gwale, the research can inform policy decisions aimed at improving these programs. For instance, understanding the specific challenges that youths face in accessing vocational education could lead to targeted interventions that make these programs more inclusive and effective. Additionally, the study’s findings could help in aligning vocational training more closely with the demands of the local economy, ensuring that the skills being taught are relevant and marketable.
Thirdly, the research has the potential to benefit the community of Gwale Local Government directly. By identifying the gaps and challenges in the current vocational education system, the study could lead to improvements that enhance the employability of local youths. This, in turn, could reduce the unemployment rate, contribute to economic growth, and improve the overall quality of life in the area. The research could also serve as a model for other regions facing similar challenges, thereby having a broader impact beyond Gwale.
Finally, the study contributes to the academic literature on vocational education and youth unemployment, particularly in the Nigerian context. It fills a gap in the existing research by providing empirical evidence on the effectiveness of vocational education in a specific local government area. The study’s findings could be used as a reference for future research in related fields, helping to build a more comprehensive understanding of how vocational education can be leveraged to address unemployment in different contexts.Top of FormBottom of Form
1.6 Scope /Delimitation of the Study
This study focuses on assessing the impact of vocational education on youth unemployment within Gwale Local Government, Gwale LGA of Kano State. It specifically examines the types and availability of vocational education programs, their effectiveness in reducing unemployment among youths aged 15-34, and the challenges faced by these youths in accessing such programs. The research is geographically limited to Gwale and considers data from the past five years -). By concentrating on vocational education, the study aims to provide insights that can inform local policy and program improvements, while acknowledging its focus on a specific population and region.
1.7 Definitions of Terms
The following terms are defined as they are going to be used in this study.
Vocational: A Latin word which means a calling and an invitation to understand some important tasks.
Unemployment: Unemployment implies lack of employment or refers to a situation where people are not able to find paid work.
Youth: a young person who has not yet reached adulthood and refers to the time period before childhood and adulthood.
Skills: An ability and capacity acquired through deliberate systematic and sustained effort to smoothly and adaptively carryout complex activities or job function involving ideas, things and people
CHAPTER TWO
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
In this chapter, relevant literature were reviewed under the following sub-heading.
2.1 Concept of Vocational Education
2.2 Concept of Unemployment
2.3 Impact of Vocational Education among Youths in Gwale LGA of Kano State
2.4 Impact of Unemployment among Youth in Gwale LGA of Kano State
2.5 Challenges faced by youths in accessing vocational education in Gwale local government area.
2.6 Summary of the Literature Reviewed
2.1 Concept of Vocational Education
Vocational education, also known as career and technical education (CTE), goes beyond simply teaching theoretical knowledge. It's a distinct educational approach designed to equip individuals with the specific skills and practical abilities needed to thrive in a chosen career field (Ward & McClintock, 2017). Unlike traditional academic programs with a broad focus, vocational education emphasizes a targeted curriculum. Students delve into areas directly relevant to their desired profession, such as learning the intricacies of automotive repair, mastering the intricacies of software development, or gaining expertise in culinary arts (Hossler & Wegner, 2017). This focus translates into a curriculum rich in practical skills development. The cornerstone of vocational education lies in its hands-on learning approach. Gone are the days of solely memorizing facts from textbooks. Vocational programs integrate classroom instruction with workshops, practical activities, and real-world projects (Hossler & Wegner, 2017). Students gain valuable experience by working on equipment they will encounter in the workplace, simulating real-world scenarios, and applying their knowledge in practical settings.
Furthermore, vocational education often fosters strong industry connections. Programs that collabourate with local businesses and industry leaders create valuable partnerships that enhance vocational education. These collaborations help align the training offered with the actual skills and expertise required by the labour market, ensuring that participants are better prepared for employment. Additionally, such partnerships can provide students with hands-on experience, internships, and potential job placements, improving their chances of securing employment after completing the program (Ward & McClintock, 2017). This approach helps bridge the gap between education and practical job market demands. This collaboration can take many forms, such as guest lectures from industry professionals, internships that provide practical experience, or curriculum development tailored to meet the specific skill sets sought after by employers. These connections not only enrich the learning experience but also enhance graduates' employability by ensuring their skillset aligns with current workforce needs.
2.2 Concept of Unemployment
Unemployment is a critical socio-economic issue that arises when individuals who are willing and able to work are unable to find suitable employment. It is an important indicator of an economy's health, reflecting the gap between the supply of labour and the demand for it within a particular market. The International Labour Organization (ILO) defines unemployment as the situation where individuals above a specified age are without work, are currently available for work, and are actively seeking for employment (ILO, 2020). The prevalence of unemployment not only signals economic inefficiencies but also poses significant social challenges, including poverty, inequality, and social unrest. Unemployment is typically classified into several categories, each reflecting different underlying causes. Frictional unemployment occurs when workers transition between jobs, careers, or locations, and is generally considered a natural and temporary part of a dynamic economy (Bivens & Zipperer, 2018). Structural unemployment results from long-term shifts in the economy that alter the demand for certain skills, often due to technological advancements or changes in consumer preferences. This type of unemployment is particularly troubling because it reflects a disconnect between workers' skills and employers' needs, which can lead to prolonged periods of joblessness for those impacted (Autor, 2019). Cyclical unemployment is linked to the business cycle, where job losses occur during economic downturns and recessions, reflecting reduced demand for goods and services (Blanchard & Johnson, 2021). Finally, seasonal unemployment is experienced in industries that have fluctuating labour demands based on the time of year, such as agriculture or tourism (Jones & Thomas, 2020).
In developing countries like Nigeria, unemployment is a pervasive challenge, particularly among the youth. According to the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS), the youth unemployment rate in Nigeria has reached alarming levels, with estimates exceeding 40% in recent years (NBS, 2023). This high rate of youth unemployment is often attributed to several factors, including inadequate education and vocational training systems, insufficient economic growth, and structural issues within the labour market. The consequences of youth unemployment are profound, leading to increased poverty, social discontent, and a higher likelihood of young people engaging in criminal activities as they struggle to make ends meet (Ogunlela, 2018). Unemployment is most commonly measured by the unemployment rate, which is the percentage of the labour force that is unemployed and actively seeking work. While this metric provides a snapshot of labour market conditions, it may not fully capture the complexities of underemployment, where individuals may be working in jobs that do not fully utilize their skills or provide sufficient income (ILO, 2020). High unemployment rates typically signal economic distress, while low unemployment rates suggest that most people who want to work can find jobs. However, the quality and sustainability of those jobs are also critical considerations in assessing the overall employment landscape.
Addressing unemployment requires a multifaceted approach that includes economic policies aimed at stimulating job creation, improving education and vocational training systems, and ensuring that labour market regulations support both employers and workers. Vocational education, in particular, has been highlighted as a key strategy for reducing unemployment, especially among young people. By providing practical, job-specific skills, vocational training can enhance employability and enable young people to either secure employment or start their own businesses (Adams, 2019). In the context of Nigeria, strengthening vocational education could be instrumental in tackling the high rates of youth unemployment and fostering long-term economic development.
2.3 Impact of Vocational Education Among Youths in Gwale LGA of Kano State
In Gwale, a region with a significant youth population, vocational education holds immense potential to empower young people and contribute to the state's economic development. Here's a closer look at the positive impacts vocational education can have on Kano's youth: Studies like one by Idris & Mbudai (2016) highlight that vocational education equips youth with job-ready skills, making them more competitive in the labour market. By focusing on practical skills relevant to specific trades, vocational programs bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical application. This directly translates graduates who can immediately contribute to the workforce, reducing unemployment rates among Gwale’s youth.
Vocational education can foster a spirit of entrepreneurship among young people. Research by Ali Idris (2012) suggests that vocational programs can equip graduates with the necessary skills to not only secure employment but also to start their own businesses. Learning skills like business management, marketing, and financial planning alongside their chosen trade, empowers youth to become self-employed and contribute to economic growth. Youth unemployment is a significant contributor to poverty. As vocational education increases employability and fosters entrepreneurship, it has the potential to alleviate poverty among Kano's youth. With stable incomes and the ability to create job opportunities for others, vocational graduates can improve their own socioeconomic stand and contribute to the overall economic well-being of the state (Ochiaga, 2015).
Vocational education plays a role in promoting social development by providing disadvantaged youth with a clear path to a better future. By offering an alternative to traditional academic education and equipping them with valuable skills, vocational programs can steer young people away from idleness and potentially decrease involvement in social problems like crime (Nwoye, 2011). It's important to acknowledge that vocational education in Kano also faces challenges. Studies by Idris et al. (2017) point to the need for curriculum improvements that prioritize practical training alongside theoretical knowledge. Additionally, ensuring teachers have access to proper training and up-to-date industry knowledge is crucial for effective skills development (Ogundele, 2010). Vocational education offers a powerful tool for empowering Kano' youths, by equipping them with job-ready skills, fostering entrepreneurship, and reducing poverty, vocational programs have the potential to contribute significantly to the state's social and economic development. Addressing existing challenges within the vocational education system will be key to maximizing its positive impact on Kano youths.
2.4 Impact of Unemployment Among Youths in Gwale Local Government Gwale LGA of Kano State
Unemployment among youth in Gwale LGA of Kano State posed serious socio-economic challenge, with far-reaching implications for both the individuals affected and the broader community. The persistent lack of job opportunities for young people has profound economic, social, and psychological consequences that collectively undermine the region's potential for growth and development. Economic Impact: The economic repercussions of youth unemployment in Gwale LGA of Kano State are significant, leading to widespread financial instability. Unemployed youth, without a steady income, face difficulties in meeting their basic needs and contributing to their households, thereby perpetuating cycles of poverty within their families. This situation not only affects the individual youths but also has broader economic consequences, as reduced consumer spending weakens local businesses and decreases overall economic activity in the state. Moreover, the inability of young people to secure gainful employment limits their capacity to invest in further education, entrepreneurial ventures, or other activities that could enhance their economic prospects and contribute to the state's economic growth (Adebayo & Okafor, 2021). The cumulative effect of these economic challenges is a reduction in the tax base, which in turn impacts the state's ability to fund public services and infrastructure, further exacerbating socio-economic disparities.
Social Impact: The social ramifications of youth unemployment in Gwale LGA of Kano State are equally troubling. The lack of employment opportunities often leads to feelings of frustration, marginalization, and social exclusion among young people. This disenfranchisement can drive some youths toward anti-social behaviors, including crime, drug abuse, and violence, as they seek alternative means of survival in the absence of legitimate employment opportunities (Oluwatobi & Ogunleye, 2020). Additionally, high unemployment rates can fuel social unrest and instability, particularly in a context where youth make up a large proportion of the population. This unrest may manifest in protests, civil disobedience, or even communal conflicts, as unemployed youths express their dissatisfaction with their economic conditions. The erosion of social cohesion, driven by unemployment, can also deepen ethnic and religious tensions within the state, leading to further polarization and conflict.
Psychological Impact: The psychological effects of unemployment on youth in Gwale LGA of Kano State are profound and often overlooked. The inability to find employment can severely impact young people's self-esteem and mental health, leading to feelings of worthlessness, depression, and anxiety. These psychological burdens are particularly heavy in a cultural context where employment is closely tied to social status and identity. For many young people, the pressure to provide for their families, coupled with the stigma of unemployment, exacerbates mental health challenges and can lead to long-term psychological issues (Aminu & Usman, 2019). The psychological impact of unemployment also affects social relationships, as individuals struggling with mental health issues may withdraw from social interactions, further isolating themselves from their communities.
Impact on Development: The high rate of youth unemployment in Gwale LGA of Kano State poses a significant barrier to the region's development. A large, unemployed youth population represents a wasted resource in terms of human capital, as the skills, knowledge, and potential of these young people are not being harnessed to drive economic and social progress. This underutilization of human resources hinders the state's ability to achieve sustainable development goals, as a substantial portion of the population remains economically inactive (Bello, 2022). Furthermore, the persistent problem of unemployment may deter both domestic and foreign investment in the region, as investors may perceive the high levels of unemployment and associated social unrest as risks to their investments. Without adequate investment, the region may struggle to develop the infrastructure and industries needed to create jobs and stimulate economic growth, leading to a vicious cycle of unemployment and underdevelopment.
Therefore, the impact of youth unemployment in Gwale LGA of Kano State is extensive, affecting the economic, social, psychological, and developmental fabric of the region. Addressing this challenge requires a holistic approach that includes improving access to quality education and vocational training, fostering job creation, and implementing policies that support youth entrepreneurship and economic participation.
2.5 Challenges Faced by Youths in Accessing Vocational Education in Gwale LGA.
The challenges faced by youths in accessing vocational education in Gwale Local Government Area (LGA) reflect a range of socio-economic, infrastructural, and cultural barriers that hinder the effective participation of young individuals in vocational training programs. One of the primary obstacles is the insufficient funding and resources allocated to vocational education programs in the region. According to Adebisi and Oni (2021), many vocational education initiatives in Nigeria suffer from inadequate funding, which affects the quality of training materials, facilities, and the availability of skilled instructors. In Gwale LGA, this lack of financial support often results in poorly equipped training centers, thereby limiting the opportunities available for youths to acquire the skills necessary for gainful employment.
Another significant challenge is the limited access to quality training centers. Many vocational training programs in Gwale LGA are not easily accessible to all youths, particularly those in rural or economically disadvantaged areas. Emeh (2019) notes that a significant portion of Nigeria’s youth population resides in areas with limited access to modern vocational training facilities. Without access to such facilities, young people are unable to acquire the relevant technical skills that could enhance their employability. In some instances, existing training programs do not offer specialized or in-demand courses that align with the evolving needs of the labour market, further limiting the career prospects of those who do engage in vocational education.
Socio-cultural factors also play a crucial role in hindering youths from pursuing vocational education. In many Nigerian communities, including Gwale LGA, there is a cultural preference for formal academic education over vocational training. This preference is often rooted in the societal belief that vocational careers are less prestigious or associated with lower socioeconomic status (Adeola & Fayomi, 2019). As a result, many youths may feel compelled to pursue traditional academic education, even when vocational education could provide more direct pathways to employment. This cultural stigma surrounding vocational education limits the number of young people willing to engage in such programs, despite the increasing need for skilled labour in various sectors.
Additionally, there is often a mismatch between the skills taught in vocational education programs and the needs of the labour market. According to Ward and McClintock (2017), vocational education programs should be aligned with the demands of local industries to effectively reduce unemployment. However, in Gwale LGA, the disconnect between vocational training and industry requirements contributes to the inefficiency of these programs. Without proper alignment, many graduates of vocational programs struggle to find employment, as their skills may not match the specific needs of local employers. This misalignment reinforces the cycle of unemployment and underemployment among the youth in the region.
2.6 Summary of Literature Review
Vocational education, also known as career and technical education (CTE), is designed to provide individuals with specific skills and practical abilities essential for a chosen career. Unlike traditional education, which is broad and theory-focused, vocational education emphasizes hands-on learning tailored to particular trades or professions. The curriculum in vocational education is rich in practical skills and often involves close collaboration with industry professionals, ensuring that graduates are equipped with the skills required by employers. This approach not only enhances employability but also bridges the gap between academic knowledge and practical application, making vocational education a critical tool for workforce development (Ward & McClintock, 2017; Hossler & Wegner, 2017).
In Gwale LGA of Kano State, Nigeria, vocational education plays a vital role in addressing youth unemployment. By providing job-ready skills, vocational programs make young people more competitive in the labour market. These programs also promote entrepreneurship by equipping graduates with business management skills, enabling them to start their own ventures and contribute to the local economy. Vocational education helps alleviate poverty by increasing employability, which in turn raises the socio-economic status of the youth. Additionally, it offers at-risk youth an alternative path, potentially reducing their involvement in crime and other social issues. However, the effectiveness of vocational education in Kano is challenged by outdated curricula and inadequate teacher training, highlighting the need for system improvements to maximize its positive impact (Nwoye, 2011; Ali Idris, 2012; Ochiaga, 2015; Idris & Mbudai, 2016).
Unemployment is a critical socio-economic issue where individuals willing and able to work are unable to find suitable employment. It serves as an indicator of economic health, reflecting the mismatch between labour supply and demand. Unemployment can be classified into frictional, structural, cyclical, and seasonal types, each with different underlying causes. In Nigeria, youth unemployment is a pervasive challenge, exacerbated by inadequate education systems, slow economic growth, and structural labour market issues. The high youth unemployment rate in Nigeria has significant social consequences, including increased poverty, social discontent, and higher crime rates, as young people struggle to find work (Bivens & Zipperer, 2018; Autor, 2019; ILO, 2020; Blanchard & Johnson, 2021).
Youth unemployment in Gwale LGA of Kano State has far-reaching economic, social, and psychological consequences. Economically, unemployment leads to financial instability, reducing consumer spending and weakening local businesses. It also limits young people's ability to invest in further education or entrepreneurship, perpetuating cycles of poverty. Socially, unemployment fosters frustration and social exclusion, driving some youth toward crime and violence. High unemployment rates can also lead to social unrest and instability, exacerbating ethnic and religious tensions. Psychologically, unemployment severely impacts mental health, leading to depression, anxiety, and social withdrawal. This not only affects the individuals but also hinders the region's overall development by underutilizing human capital and deterring investment, creating a cycle of unemployment and underdevelopment (Aminu & Usman, 2019; Oluwatobi & Ogunleye, 2020; Adebayo & Okafor, 2021; Bello, 2022).
The literature reviewed highlights the significant impact of both vocational education and unemployment on youths in Gwale LGA of Kano State. Vocational education is crucial for reducing unemployment and fostering economic development, but it faces challenges that need to be addressed to maximize its benefits. Unemployment, on the other hand, has extensive negative consequences that hinder both individual well-being and regional development. Addressing these issues requires a comprehensive approach that includes improving vocational education, creating job opportunities, and supporting youth entrepreneurship.
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter is concerned with the presentation of the method used in carrying out the study and is presented under the following subheading:
3.1 Research Design
3.2 Population of the Study
3.3 Sample Size and Sampling Technique
3.4 Instrument for Data Collection
3.5 Validity and Reliability of the Instrument
3.6 Procedure for Data Collection
3.7 Procedure for Data Analysis
3.1 Research Design
The research design adopted for this study is descriptive survey. Descriptive Survey research design according to Rezigalla (2020) is a form of research design used when dealing with a very systematic collection of data or information from population or sample of the population through the use of personal interview opinion scale, questionnaire and observation. Sileyew (2019) also viewed survey research design as a study which involves an investigation on entire population of people or items by collecting data from sample drawn from population and assuming that these samples are representative of the entire population.
The researchers choose the research design for this study because it is suitable for systematic collection choose of data from a specific population or a sample that represents the population. This design allows for gathering a wide range of information through various methods, such as questionnaires, interviews, and observations, making it ideal for exploring the perspectives, experiences, and behaviors of the participants. Descriptive Survey research design is particularly effective when dealing with large population, as it enables the researcher to draw conclusions about the entire population based on the data collected from a representative sample (Rezigalla, 2020; Sileyew, 2019). This approach provides the flexibility to investigate multiple variables and relationships within the data, making it possible to analyze the impact of vocational education on youth unemployment in a comprehensive and systematic manner. Additionally, the survey research design is advantageous because it allows for the collection of both quantitative and qualitative data, providing a more holistic understanding of the research problem. This design is also cost-effective and time-efficient, which is essential for conducting a study within a defined time frame and budget.
3.2 Population of the Study
The population of the study refers to the entire group of individuals or entities that are the focus of the research. In this study, the population consists 588,500 of all youths in Gwale Local Government Area of Gwale LGA of Kano State, who are relevant to the research, on the impact of vocational education on youth unemployment. Table showing the population of Gwale Local Government Area in Gwale LGA of Kano State, broken down by gender based on the 2024 population projection:
Gender
Population
Male
298,300
Female
290,200
Total
588,500
This distribution indicates a slight male majority in the population of Gwale Local Government.
3.3 Sample Size and Sampling Technique
The sample size was determined using the formula for a finite population:
where:
n = sample size
N = desired sample size from an infinite population
Ntotal = total population size (588,500 in this case)
For a population of 588,500 in Gwale Local Government Area, a sample size of 384 youths is appropriate for a 95% confidence level and a 5% margin of error. This sample size will allow you to gather representative data and make valid inferences about the impact of vocational education on youth unemployment in the area.
For this study on the impact of vocational education on youths’ unemployment in Gwale Local Government Area, stratified random sampling is a suitable technique. This method ensures that different subgroups within the population are proportionately represented in the sample, providing a more comprehensive view of the impact across various segments of the population.
Gender
Population
Sample size
Male
298,300
194
Female
290,200
190
Total
588,500
384
3.4 Instrument for Data Collection
In this research work, structured questionnaire was used in the data collection, the researchers used a self-developed questionnaire, and the questionnaire elicited responses from the respondents in Gwale Local Government. Likert Scale format i.e., Agree, Strongly Agree, Disagree and Strongly Disagree was used.
3.5 Validity of the Instrument
According to Ferreira et al., (2021) an instrument for research could be valid when it measures what is supposed to measure. Therefore, to establish the validity of the instrument, experts and professionals was consulted from Department of Business Education, Federal College of Education Kano for further corrections and suggestions before final draft, their corrections and suggestions were incorporated.
3.6 Reliability of the Instrument
Pilot study was conducted to establish the reliability of the instruments. Therefore, test and retest method of establishing reliability was applied. In this study, a sample of questionnaires were selected to the Gwale Local Government for pilot testing.
3.7 Procedure for Data Collection
Three hundred and eighty-four (384) copies of the questionnaires were distributed to the youths in Gwale local government of Gwale LGA of Kano State. The researchers adopted self-administration method of test administration in the sense that the researcher administered the questionnaire to the respondents and then collected them back for analysis. The completed questionnaires were collected back and checked and ensured that the respondents complied with the instruction given in the questionnaires.
The questionnaire was retrieved from the respondents by the researchers from which only three hundred and forty-six (346) out of three hundred and eighty four (384) were retrieved.
3.8 Procedure for Data Analysis
In this research work, the collected data was subjected to statistical analysis. The researcher employed tables, simple percentages, frequency counts, and weighted mean scores standard deviation to analyze the responses gathered from the respondents.
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION, AND ANALYSIS
Chapter Four presents and analyzes data collected from 384 respondents, focusing on vocational education's impact on youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government of Gwale LGA of Kano State. It details on respondents' demographics data. The chapter uses tables and statistical analyses to interpret the findings and provide insights.
4.1 Demographic Data of the Respondents
Table 4.2.1 Gender
Gender
Frequency
Percentage (%)
Male
177
51.2%
Female
169
48.8%
Total
346
100%
Table 4.2.1 presents the gender distribution of respondents in the study. Out of a total of 346 participants, 177 (51.2%) were male, while 169 (48.8%) were female. This shows a nearly equal representation of both genders, providing a balanced viewpoint in the research findings.
Table 4.2.2 Age Group
Age Group
Frequency
Percentage (%-
Total-
Table 4.2.2 illustrates the age distribution of respondents. Among the 346 participants, the largest age group was 26–30 years, comprising 109 individuals (31.5%), followed by the 21–25 and 31–35 age groups, each with 87 individuals (25.1%). The 15–20 age group accounted for 63 respondents (18.2%). This distribution shows that the majority of respondents were within the 26–35 age range, aligning with the study's focus on youth.
Table 4.2.3 Level of Education
Level of Education
Frequency
Percentage (%)
Primary
53
15.3
Secondary
170
49.1
Tertiary
123
35.6
Total-
Table 4.2.3 presents the educational qualifications of the respondents. Out of 346 participants, 170 individuals (49.1%) had secondary education, 123 (35.6%) had tertiary education, and 53 (15.3%) had primary education. This suggests that a majority of respondents had at least a secondary education, potentially enhancing their access to and understanding of vocational education programs.
Table 4.2.4 Employment Status
Employment Status
Frequency
Percentage (%)
Employed
66
19.1
Unemployed
42
12.1
Self-employed
238
68.8
Total-
Table 4.2.4 shows respondents’ employment status. Of the 346 participants, 238 (68.8%) were self-employed, 66 (19.1%) were employed, and 42 (12.1%) were unemployed. This indicates a strong presence of self-employment among youths, possibly influenced by vocational education initiatives within the area.
Table 4.2.5 Marital Status
Marital Status
Frequency
Percentage (%)
Single
140
40.5
Married
161
46.5
Divorced
45
13.0
Others
0
0.0
Total-
Table 4.2.5 presents the marital status of the respondents. Out of 346 participants, the majority, 161 individuals (46.5%), were married, followed by 140 individuals (40.5%) who were single. A smaller group of 45 respondents (13.0%) were divorced, and no participants reported any other marital status. This distribution shows that married individuals formed the largest segment, providing insights into the demographic structure of the population under study.
4.2 Research Questions
Table 4.3.1 What is the current rate of youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government, and what factors contribute to it?
Question
A
SA
DA
SD
Mean Score
S. Dev.
Decision
Gwale L.G.A of Kano was the highest rate of youths unemployment-
Accepted
Lack of access to quality education contributes significantly to youth high rate of unemployment in the area-
Accepted
Poor economic opportunities are a major factor leading to unemployment among youth in Gwale Local Government-
Accepted
Many unemployed youths in Gwale Local Government lack the skills demanded by local employers-
Accepted
Government interventions is insufficient to address youths unemployment in Gwale Local Government-
Accepted
There are adequate job opportunities available for youths in Gwale Local Government. -
Rejected
Most unemployed youths in Gwale are unwilling to take vocational jobs available to them. -
Rejected
Youth unemployment in Gwale is under control and not a major concern for the local government-
Rejected
Cultural factors have little to no impact on youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government. -
Rejected
Local businesses contribute actively to reducing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government-
Accepted
The results presented in Table 4.3.1 reveal key insights into the perceptions of respondents regarding the current rate of youth unemployment and its contributing factors in Gwale Local Government. A majority of respondents affirmed that youth unemployment is very high in the area, with a strong consensus that lack of access to quality education, poor economic opportunities, and a mismatch between youth skills and employer demands are major contributing factors—each receiving high mean scores above 3.90 and thus accepted. Government interventions were also perceived as insufficient, further highlighting systemic gaps in addressing unemployment. Conversely, statements suggesting that adequate job opportunities exist, that youths are unwilling to take up vocational jobs, or that unemployment is not a concern for the local government, all received low mean scores below 2.50 and were rejected. Additionally, cultural factors were not seen as significant contributors. Notably, local businesses were recognized as playing a moderately active role in reducing youth unemployment, though this effort alone appears inadequate to reverse the broader trend. These findings underscore a general agreement among respondents that youth unemployment in Gwale is a critical issue driven largely by structural, educational, and economic inadequacies.
Table 4.3.2 To what extent are vocational education programs available to youths in Gwale Local Government Area?
Question
A
SA
DA
SD
Mean Score
St. Dev.
Decision
Vocational education programs are not widely available in Gwale Local Government-
Accepted
The training centers in Gwale are well-equipped for vocational education-
Rejected
Youth in Gwale are not aware of the vocational education programs available to them-
Accepted
The cost of enrolling in vocational programs is not affordable for most youths in Gwale-
Rejected
Vocational education programs in Gwale are not accessible to youths from diverse backgrounds-
Rejected
There are several vocational education programs available in Gwale Local Government -
Rejected
Most youths in Gwale does face challenges in accessing vocational training centers. -
Rejected
Vocational training in Gwale is not designed to meet the needs of the local population. -
Rejected
The Kano State government is highly supportive of vocational education programs in Gwale Local Government. -
Accepted
Private organizations play an important role in supporting vocational education in Gwale Local Government. -
Accepted
The results in Table 4.3.2 provide insight into the perceived availability of vocational education programs for youths in Gwale Local Government Area. Respondents generally agreed that vocational programs are available (Mean = 3.02) and that both the government (Mean = 3.11) and private organizations (Mean = 3.11) play supportive roles, with these items being accepted. Additionally, awareness of these programs among youths was rated positively (Mean = 3.14), indicating that information dissemination is relatively effective. However, several aspects of vocational education availability were rated poorly. Respondents disagreed that training centers are well-equipped (Mean = 2.82), that enrollment is affordable (Mean = 2.59), and that the programs are accessible to all backgrounds (Mean = 2.95), with these items being rejected. Furthermore, negative perceptions were evident in the responses to questions regarding limited availability (Mean = 2.33), accessibility challenges (Mean = 2.55), and relevance of vocational training to local needs (Mean = 2.26), all of which were rejected. These findings suggest that while there is general awareness and institutional support for vocational education in Gwale, substantial barriers remain in terms of infrastructure, affordability, and inclusivity, limiting the full potential and impact of these programs on youth development.
Table 4.3.3 What is the effectiveness of vocational education programs in reducing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government?
Question
SA
A
N
DA
SD
Mean Score
Std Dev
Decision
Vocational education programs in Gwale help to equip youths with practical job skills-
Accepted
Youths who graduate from vocational programs in Gwale often secure employment-
Rejected
Vocational training in Gwale effectively promotes entrepreneurship among youths-
Accepted
The skills taught in vocational programs align with the needs of local industries-
Rejected
Vocational education programs in Gwale contribute to reducing unemployment poverty in the area-
Rejected
Vocational training in Gwale does not provide youths with marketable skills. -
Rejected
Most youths trained through vocational programs in Gwale remains unemployed. -
Rejected
Entrepreneurship training in vocational programs has limited impact on Gwale youths. -
Rejected
Graduates of vocational education in Gwale play a key role in boosting the local government's economic development-
Accepted
Graduates from vocational programs in Gwale are capable of starting their own businesses. -
Accepted
The findings on table 4.3.3 reveal that vocational education programs in Gwale Local Government are effective in equipping youths with practical job skills (Mean=4.02, Accepted) and promoting entrepreneurship (Mean=3.65, Accepted). Graduates also reported high confidence in starting businesses (Mean=3.82, Accepted) and acknowledged the positive economic contributions of vocational training (Mean=3.68, Accepted). However, the programs face significant challenges in translating skills into employment, as evidenced by the low mean score for job placement (Mean=3.32, Rejected) and misalignment with industry needs (Mean=3.25, Rejected). Additionally, vocational education’s impact on poverty reduction was deemed insufficient (Mean=3.10, Rejected). Notably, respondents rejected negative statements, such as claims that vocational training fails to provide marketable skills (Mean=2.01) or leaves graduates unemployed (Mean=2.20), reinforcing confidence in the programs’ foundational value. Overall, while vocational training succeeds in skill development and entrepreneurial motivation, structural gaps in job market alignment and post-training support hinder its full potential in reducing youth unemployment. Recommendations include strengthening industry partnerships, revising curricula to match labor demands, and enhancing access to startup capital for graduates.
4.3 Summary of Major Findings
1. High Unemployment Driven by Structural Gaps: Respondents overwhelmingly agreed that Gwale faces severe youth unemployment due to inadequate education, economic opportunities, and skills mismatch (Means >3.90). Government interventions were deemed insufficient, while cultural factors were dismissed as insignificant.
2. Vocational Programs Available but Limited by Barriers: While vocational training exists and enjoys government/private support (Means ≥3.11), critical accessibility issues persist, including poorly equipped centers, high costs, and lack of inclusivity (Means ≤2.95), hindering broader impact.
3. Skills Development Strong, Employment Outcomes Weak: Vocational education effectively builds skills and entrepreneurship (Means ≥3.65), but fails to secure jobs (Mean=3.32) or align with industry needs (Mean=3.25). Poverty reduction remains low (Mean=3.10), calling for curriculum reforms and post-training support.
4.4 Discussions of Findings
The demographic distribution of respondents in this study reveals important insights about vocational education participation in Gwale Local Government. With nearly equal gender representation (51.2% male, 48.8% female), the findings align with contemporary research emphasizing gender inclusivity in vocational training programs (World Bank, 2020). However, the predominance of respondents aged 26-35 years (56.6%) reflects Nigeria's broader youth unemployment crisis, particularly affecting young adults in their prime working years (National Bureau of Statistics [NBS], 2022). This demographic concentration supports Adebayo and Adebisi's (2021) argument that vocational education programs in Nigeria primarily serve mid-career youths seeking skills upgrading rather than fresh school leavers. The educational profile of respondents, with 49.1% having secondary education and 35.6% possessing tertiary qualifications, mirrors findings by Okoli and Eze (2022) that vocational programs in Northern Nigeria predominantly attract moderately educated youth who face barriers to formal employment.
The study's findings on youth unemployment drivers corroborate existing literature on structural labor market challenges in Nigeria. Respondents identified lack of quality education, limited economic opportunities, and skills mismatch as primary contributors (means >3.90), consistent with Oluwajodu et al.'s (2021) analysis of Nigeria's employment crisis. The rejection of cultural factors as significant barriers (mean <2.50) challenges common assumptions about Northern Nigeria's labor market and aligns with recent findings by Musa and Ibrahim (2023) that emphasize policy failures over cultural resistance. The perceived insufficiency of government interventions supports Emeh's (2022) critique of Nigeria's fragmented vocational education policies, which often lack adequate funding and implementation frameworks. However, the moderate rating of private sector involvement (mean ≈3.11) suggests potential for public-private partnerships, as advocated by the International Labour Organization (ILO, 2021) in its recommendations for African labor markets.
Analysis of vocational program effectiveness reveals both strengths and systemic challenges. The high ratings for skill acquisition (mean=4.02) and entrepreneurship promotion (mean=3.65) validate UNESCO's (2021) findings on the transformative potential of vocational education in developing economies. However, the low scores for job placement (mean=3.32) and industry alignment (mean=3.25) reflect persistent curriculum deficiencies identified by Adeoye et al. (2022) in their evaluation of Nigerian technical schools. The infrastructure deficits (mean=2.82) and affordability challenges (mean=2.59) mirror World Bank (2022) reports on underfunded vocational systems across Sub-Saharan Africa. These findings collectively suggest that while vocational education shows promise in Gwale, its impact remains constrained by implementation gaps that scholars like Ajufo (2023) attribute to poor policy coordination and inadequate resource allocation.
The study's findings have significant implications for vocational education policy in Northern Nigeria. First, the strong performance in skills development but weak employment outcomes suggests the need for closer industry collaboration, as demonstrated in successful models like Germany's dual vocational system (Eichhorst & Rinne, 2021). Second, the accessibility barriers highlight the urgency of funding reforms proposed by the African Development Bank (2022) to make vocational training more inclusive. Third, the moderate private sector involvement indicates opportunities for expanding apprenticeship programs, a strategy that has reduced youth unemployment in comparable contexts like Kenya (KIPPRA, 2021). These recommendations align with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal 8, which emphasizes quality technical education for inclusive economic growth (United Nations, 2023).
This study provides empirical evidence that vocational education in Gwale Local Government effectively develops skills but struggles with employment outcomes due to systemic implementation challenges. The findings reinforce existing scholarship on Nigeria's vocational education system while offering localized insights for policymakers.
CHAPTER FIVE
SUMMAR, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Summary
This research investigated the effectiveness of vocational education programs in addressing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government, Kano State. The study employed a mixed-methods approach, collecting data from 346 respondents across various demographic groups. The findings reveal a complex picture of vocational education's impact on youth employment outcomes.
Regarding youth unemployment, the study found overwhelming consensus among respondents about the severity of the problem in Gwale. Structural factors such as inadequate access to quality education, limited economic opportunities, and significant skills mismatch emerged as primary contributors to high unemployment rates. These findings align with broader national trends documented by the National Bureau of Statistics (2022) and corroborate similar studies in Northern Nigeria by Musa and Ibrahim (2023). Interestingly, cultural factors were not perceived as significant barriers, challenging some common assumptions about vocational education uptake in the region.
The examination of vocational education programs yielded mixed results. While respondents acknowledged the availability of vocational training opportunities and their effectiveness in imparting practical skills, several critical shortcomings were identified. Infrastructure deficiencies, high program costs, and poor alignment with industry needs significantly limited the programs' overall impact. These findings echo concerns raised by the World Bank (2022) about vocational education systems across Sub-Saharan Africa and provide specific evidence of these challenges in the Gwale context.
5.2 Conclusion
Based on the comprehensive analysis of collected data, this study concludes that vocational education in Gwale Local Government demonstrates significant potential but falls short of delivering substantial reductions in youth unemployment. The programs successfully equip participants with practical skills and foster entrepreneurial mindsets, as evidenced by the positive ratings in these areas. However, the translation of these skills into meaningful employment opportunities remains inadequate.
The primary obstacles identified - including systemic implementation challenges, resource constraints, and curriculum misalignment - mirror findings from similar studies across Nigeria. These limitations significantly undermine the potential benefits of vocational training. Nevertheless, the strong rejection of negative perceptions about vocational education's fundamental value suggests a foundation of community support that could be leveraged for program improvement.
5.3 Recommendations
1. Government should make vocational training more accessible and affordable to youths, possibly through subsidies or community-based training centers.
2. Vocational programs should be tailored to meet local industry needs to ensure that graduates acquire marketable skills that match available job opportunities.
3. Programs aimed at supporting graduates in finding employment or starting their own businesses should be strengthened. This could include mentorship, networking opportunities, and partnerships with local businesses.
4. Despite a positive perception of vocational education, further efforts should be made to increase awareness and participation, particularly among marginalized or underrepresented groups.
5. Future studies should evaluate the long-term impact of vocational education on employment outcomes to measure its effectiveness in reducing unemployment and enhancing economic opportunities for youths in the region.
REFERENCES
Adamu, U., Sulaimon, B. O., & Adeyemi, J. O. (2022). Gender and employment dynamics in youth employment in Nigeria. Journal of Gender Studies, 29(2), 115-130.
Adebayo, O., & Adebisi, T. (2021). Youth unemployment and vocational education in Nigeria: A critical analysis. Journal of African Development Studies, 14(2), 45-62.
Adeoye, M. A., Oluwajodu, F., & Emeh, I. E. (2022). Technical and vocational education in Nigeria: Policy gaps and implementation challenges. African Journal of Education and Practice, 8(1), 112-129.
African Development Bank. (2022). Skills development for Africa's industrialization. Abidjan: AfDB Publications.
Aliyu, M., Abubakar, I. M., & Shamsuddeen, A. (2023). Educational disparities and youth unemployment in sub-Saharan Africa: A case study of Nigeria. African Journal of Development Economics, 35(1), 77-90.
Balogun, F. O., & Adebayo, A. D. (2021). Socio-cultural barriers to employment in West Africa. Journal of African Social Policy, 48(3), 45-60.
Eichhorst, W., & Rinne, U. (2021). The German vocational education and training system: Lessons for Africa. IZA Journal of Labor Policy, 10(1), 1-18.
Emeh, I. E. (2022). Vocational education policy in Nigeria: Implementation challenges and prospects. Nigerian Journal of Educational Research, 15(3), 78-92.
Hossain, M. F., Khatun, S., & Rahman, R. (2022). The impact of education on youth unemployment: A case study of African nations. International Journal of Youth Studies, 29(2), 121-134.
Ibrahim, M., Musa, H., & Nuhu, I. (2023). The impact of government policies on youth employment in Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Public Policy, 11(1), 40-55.
International Labour Organization. (2021). Global employment trends for youth 2021. Geneva: ILO.
Kewi, A. D., & Asare, F. (2023). Youth unemployment and the challenge of education in developing nations. Global Education Review, 6(4), 123-135.
KIPPRA. (2021). Youth employment programs in Kenya: Lessons for Africa. Nairobi: Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research.
Musa, A., & Ibrahim, Y. (2023). Cultural perceptions and vocational education in Northern Nigeria. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 75(1), 134-150.
Mustapha, A. S., Adeyemi, A. I., & Alabi, M. K. (2022). Vocational training and its role in youth employment in Nigeria. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 44(3), 202-217.
National Bureau of Statistics. (2022). Labour force statistics: Q4 2022 report. Abuja: NBS.
Ndubuisi, A. O., Olayemi, S., & Akinwunmi, M. A. (2023). Vocational education, market demands, and youth unemployment in Nigeria. Educational Research and Reviews, 19(1), 55-70.
Ogundele, O. T. (2022). Youth unemployment and the role of vocational education in economic development. African Development Review, 33(4), 472-488.
Okoli, B. E., & Eze, T. C. (2022). Participation patterns in Nigerian vocational education programs. International Journal of Educational Development, 45(3), 201-215.
Oladele, J. O., & Okunola, O. S. (2021). Enhancing vocational education in Nigeria: Challenges and policy recommendations. Nigerian Journal of Educational Policy, 28(1), 98-112.
Olatunji, O. A., Adeyemi, S. A., & Ogundele, A. M. (2023). The relevance of vocational education to youth employment in sub-Saharan Africa. Education and Employment Journal, 30(2), 101-116.
UNESCO. (2021). Global education monitoring report: Technical and vocational education. Paris: UNESCO Publishing.
World Bank. (2022). The skills gap in Sub-Saharan Africa. Washington, DC: World Bank Publications.
APPENDIX
RESEARCH QUESTIONNAIRE
Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria
Department of Business Education
17th Nov, 2024
Dear Respondent,
We are final-year students from Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, conducting a research study on the topic: "Impact of Vocational Education on Youth Unemployment in Gwale Local Government, Kano State."
We kindly request your assistance in completing the attached questionnaire. Please tick the appropriate responses in the spaces provided. Rest assured that all information you provide will be treated with the utmost confidentiality and used strictly for academic purposes.
We sincerely appreciate your time and valuable input in contributing to the success of this research.
Thank you.
Section A: Demographic Data
Gender: Male [ ] Female [ ]
Age Group: 15–20 [ ] 21–25 [ ] 26–30 [ ] 31–35 [ ]
Level of Education: Primary [ ] Secondary [ ] Tertiary [ ]
Employment Status: Employed [ ] Unemployed [ ] Self-employed [ ]
Marital Status: Single [ ] Married [ ] Divorced [ ] Other [ ]
Section B: Research Questions
What is the current rate of youths unemployment in Gwale Local Government, and what factors contribute to it?
Question
A
SA
DA
SD
Gwale L.G.A of Kano was the highest rate of youths unemployment.
Lack of access to quality education contributes significantly to youth high rate of unemployment in the area.
Poor economic opportunities are a major factor leading to unemployment among youth in Gwale Local Government.
Many unemployed youths in Gwale Local Government lack the skills demanded by local employers.
Government interventions is insufficient to address youths unemployment in Gwale Local Government.
There are adequate job opportunities available for youths in Gwale Local Government.
Most unemployed youths in Gwale are unwilling to take vocational jobs available to them.
Youth unemployment in Gwale is under control and not a major concern for the local government
Cultural factors have little to no impact on youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government.
Local businesses contribute actively to reducing youth unemployment in Gwale Local Government.
To what extent are vocational education programs available to youths in Gwale Local Government Area?
Question
A
SA
DA
SD
Vocational education programs are not widely available in Gwale Local Government.
The training centers in Gwale are well-equipped for vocational education.
Youth in Gwale are not aware of the vocational education programs available to them.
The cost of enrolling in vocational programs is not affordable for most youths in Gwale.
Vocational education programs in Gwale are not accessible to youths from diverse backgrounds.
There are several vocational education programs available in Gwale Local Government
Most youths in Gwale does face challenges in accessing vocational training centers.
Vocational training in Gwale is not designed to meet the needs of the local population.
The Kano State government is highly supportive of vocational education programs in Gwale Local Government.
Private organizations play an important role in supporting vocational education in Gwale Local Government.
What is the effectiveness of vocational education programs in reducing youths unemployment in Gwale Local Government?
Question
A
SA
DA
SD
Vocational education programs in Gwale help to equip youths with practical job skills.
Youths who graduate from vocational programs in Gwale often secure employment.
Vocational training in Gwale effectively promotes entrepreneurship among youths.
The skills taught in vocational programs align with the needs of local industries.
Vocational education programs in Gwale contribute to reducing unemployment poverty in the area.
Vocational training in Gwale does not provide youths with marketable skills.
Most youths trained through vocational programs in Gwale remains unemployed.
Entrepreneurship training in vocational programs has limited impact on Gwale youths.
Graduates of vocational education in Gwale play a key role in boosting the local government's economic development.
Graduates from vocational programs in Gwale are capable of starting their own businesses.
Thank you for participation