5.Assignment for UK Bachelor student
PRELIMINARY
STEPS
FOR RECRUITMENT AND
ADVERSE IMPACT
CASE STUDY ANALYSIS
This document looks at the preliminary processes that
should occur before the recruitment process and also
analyzes the need to consider company’s employees for
the recruitment process. Furthermore, it looks at Olam
Resources, an organization to see if it is fulfilling the
requirements of the four-fifths rule and whether or not
the various groups for recruitment to the organization are
facing adverse impact.
Hp
[Pick the date]
Contents
PRELIMINARY STEPS BEFORE RECRUITMENT ............................................................... 3
Identify the need for recruitment ............................................................................................ 3
Develop recruitment policies .................................................................................................. 3
Develop job descriptions and person specifications ............................................................... 3
Decide on the relevant recruitment methods .......................................................................... 4
THE NEED FOR INTERNAL RECRUITMENT ...................................................................... 4
ADVERSE IMPACT ANALYSIS ............................................................................................. 5
Compliance Analysis .................................................................................................................. 6
PRELIMINARY STEPS BEFORE RECRUITMENT
There are four HR processes that must happen before the beginning of the recruitment process:
Identify the need for recruitment
The first step most important is to see if there is a vacant position and if it really needs hiring.
Also it must be considered what kind of a vacancy is it whether a newly created position or a
replacement. For a newly created position it must already be a position budgeted at the start of
the year while for a replacement it is necessary to consult with the concerned department to
know whether it is essential to fill it. Also, after having judged the need for recruitment it is
important to analyze whether the hiring will occur internally or externally. For recruitment
purposes, knowing the need for recruitment makes the HR department realize the urgency and
also calculate the budget required for recruitment.
Develop recruitment policies
Recruitment policy is needed to tell employees how they should act so they are in line with the
organization’s strategic plan. A recruitment policy must address two factors: 1) the overall goal
for recruitment and 2) the equality of opportunity. (FOOT, Margaret and Hook, Caroline, 2011)
The organizations need to include the overall goal for recruitment to see that it is well matched
with the overall strategic plan of the organization and also that it does not waste organizational
resources in the recruitment process. The need for a policy for equal opportunity is to make sure
the organization is in line with the legal requirements of not discriminating on the basis of gender
or ethnicity. (FOOT, Margaret and Hook, Caroline, 2011)
Develop job descriptions and person specifications
This step sees the development of job descriptions (JD) and person specifications. A JD contains
a job title, the super ordinate post the candidate will report to as well as the subordinate post
reporting to him/her as well as the purpose of the job along with the major tasks and duties. A
person specification contains the description of the most likely candidate according to the level
of knowledge, skills and abilities required for the job. The recruitment process needs these
documents as they allow the potential candidates to know what the job requires of them and
whether they are up to the mark while they allow the organization to know exactly what is it they
should seek in the ideal candidates. Also, they suggest the manner in which the organization
should word the job advertisements to get the most suitable candidates.
Decide on the relevant recruitment methods
According to the JDs and person specifications, there are certain recruitment methods most
suitable. The HR department must decide on these best methods, some of which are given below:
Job advertisements
Online recruitment
Application forms or CVs or typed personal statements or a combination of them.
The HR manager will also need to consider what administrative actions will be necessary to
support his/her chosen methods. For example, for walk-in submissions staff members will need
to be allocated to the task. For the recruitment process, deciding earlier on about the recruitment
method shows a crucial concern for planning ahead of time, planning within the budget and
making sure that the recruitment process is perceived positively by the candidates without
appearing biased.
THE NEED FOR INTERNAL RECRUITMENT
Some organizations give equal importance to internal and external recruitment by posting
advertisements for jobs both inside and outside the organization, while others initially seek
employees internally only. The reasons for the latter practice are:
Organizations feel they do not have to spend too much on advertisements and conducting
tests as internal job postings make use of the intra networks or job boards.
Internal employees take lesser time to fill the vacancies and to adjust to the new job.
Internal employees have taken previous workshops and training that allows them to know
what is expected at the new job.
Organizations give off nice signals to the employees that they are considered important
particularly in cases of promotions. This keeps the employees in a healthy competition to
be better and gives them motivation to perform well. (TORRINGTON, Derek et al.,
2014)
ADVERSE IMPACT ANALYSIS
Adverse impact analysis uses four fifths rule to see if the protected groups have been
discriminated against. The scores are shown in the table below. The calculation is as follows:
First determine the groups’ proportion to the total.
Those groups which are less than 2 percent in proportion to total are not considered in the
analysis, which are Blacks-Others and Gypsy/Travelers.
Next, the pass percentage or selection rate for each group is calculated.
Next, to know four fifths score, the pass percentage for each group is divided by the
percentage of the group with the highest pass percentage, which is in case of race
Caucasian 79% and in case of gender Men 72%.
Next it is evaluated if the four-fifth score for each group is below or greater than or equal
to eighty percent. Those below eighty percent faced the adverse impact and are in the red
zone while those equal to or above eighty percent are in the safe green zone. (ADVERSE
IMPACT)
Table 1. Employment Test Data
Group
Number who took
Group Proportion to
Number who
Percentage who
Four-fifth
Adverse
the test
the total
passed
passed
scores
Impact
Caucasians
717
62.5654%
563
78.5216%
NA
NO
Asian
207
18.0628%
48
23.1884%
29.5312%
YES
89
7.7661%
43
48.3146%
61.5303%
YES
11
0.9599%
2
NA
NA
NO
111
9.6859%
71
63.9640%
81.4603%
NO
11
0.9599%
1
NA
NA
NO
Men
806
70.3316%
581
72.0844%
NA
NO
Women
340
29.6684%
149
43.8235%
60.7948%
YES
Total
1146
-%
728
Pakistanis
Black
Africans
Blacksothers
Black
British
Gypsy/Trav
eler
COMPLIANCE ANALYSIS
Olam Resources is not compliant with the four fifths rule with regards to gender; women faced
the adverse impact as they were discriminated against in selection. When we consider race, Olam
Resources is not compliant with the four fifths as concerns the following groups:
Asian Pakistanis and
Black Africans
In case of Caucasians, Blacks-Others, Black British, Gypsy/Traveler and Men the organization is
compliant with the four fifths rule and these groups did not face adverse impact in the selection
process.
Bibliography
ADVERSE IMPACT. Four fifths rule. [online]. [Accessed 19 Apr 2017]. Available from World
Wide Web:
FOOT, Margaret and HOOK, Caroline. 2011. Recruitment. In: Introducing Human Resource
Management, Essex: Pearson, pp.160-184.
TORRINGTON, Derek, Laura HALL, Stephen TAYLOR, and Carol ATKINSON. 2014.
Recruitment. In: Human Resource Management, Harlow: Pearson, p.118.