WEST VIRGINIA:
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR JEFFERSON COUNTY
ERIC NEWMAN,
Case No. CC-19-2023-C-108
Plaintiff,
vs.
JUDGE: DAVID HAMMER
ARY LS 4 LLC., et al
PLAINTIFF’S ANSWER TO DEFENDANT
Defendants
ELK RIVER TRUSTEE, INC. REQUEST FOR
ADMISSIONS
TO:
DEFENDANT ELK RIVER TRUSTEE INC
CLUNK, HOOSE CO., LPA
Sarah Crichigno [10083]
Attorneys for Defendant Elk River Trustee, Inc.
495 Wolf Ledges Pkwy
Akron, OH 44311
- – telephone
- - facsimile-File No-
PLAINTIFF ANSWER OF PLAINTIFF TO DEFENDANT ELK RIVER
TRUSTEE, INC. REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
Request for Admission No. 1. Admit that Plaintiff signed the Promissory Note.
ANSWER: Deny.
Request for Admission No. 2. Admit that Plaintiff signed the Deed of Trust.
ANSWER Deny.
Request for Admission No. 3. Admit that the Deed of Trust allows for substitution.
1
ANSWER: Objection. This request request requires the Plaintiff to do a legal analysis and further,
it requests a legal opinion.
Request for Admission No. 4: Admit that Plaintiff has no actual claim against Defendant Elk
River Trustees, Inc.
ANSWER: Deny.
Request for Admission No. 5. Admit that Plaintiff has not been damaged by Defendant Elk River
Trustees, Inc.
ANSWER: Deny.
Request for Admission No. 6. Admit that Plaintiff is in monetary default under the terms of the
subject Promissory Note and Deed of Trust.
ANSWER: Deny.
Request for Admission No. 7. Admit that the Deed of Trust is recorded in the county records and
has not been released to date.
ANSWER: Objection. This request request requires the Plaintiff to do a legal analysis and further,
it requests a legal opinion.
Request for Admission No. 8. Admit that Defendant Elk River Trustees, Inc. sent Plaintiff a
response to this dispute of debt on or about July 17, 2023.
ANSWER: The Plaintiff requires clarification for this request in order to properly respond.
Request for Admission No. 9. Admit that Defendant Elk River Trustees, Inc. never foreclosed on
the subject Property.
ANSWER: Admit.
2
Request for Admission No. 10. Admit that the Deed of Trust does not require the Trustee nor any
subsequent Trustee to ascertain the amount of the outstanding debt.
ANSWER: Objection. This request request requires the Plaintiff to do a legal analysis and further,
it requests a legal opinion.
Dated May 9, 2024
RESPECTIVELY SUBMITTED
/s//_________________________
ERIC NEWMAN - Pro Se Plaintiff
158 Cornpone LN,
Harpers Ferry, WV 25425
-
Fax: -
3
CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE
I, ERIC NEWMAN, Plaintiff, Pro Se, do hereby certify that on May 9, 2024, he
served the foregoing “PLAINTIFF ANSWER OF PLAINTIFF TO DEFENDANT ELK
RIVER TRUSTEE, INC. REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS” upon all parties by depositing
true copies thereof in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, and respective attorney as
follows:
s//_________________________
ERIC NEWMAN - Pro Se Plaintiff
21520 Yorba Linda Blvd Suite G-1029
Yorba Linda, CA 92887
-
Fax: -
Email:-
DEFENDANTS ARY LS 4 LLC.
William J. Powell (W. Va. Bar No. 2961)
Kelsey Swaim Miller (W. Va. Bar No. 12574)
STEPTOE & JOHNSON PLLC
1250 Edwin Miller Blvd., Suite 300
Martinsburg, WV 25404
Tel: -
Fax: ---MADISON MANAGEMENT SERVICES
William J. Powell (W. Va. Bar No. 2961)
Kelsey Swaim Miller (W. Va. Bar No. 12574)
STEPTOE & JOHNSON PLLC
1250 Edwin Miller Blvd., Suite 300
Martinsburg, WV 25404
Tel: -
Fax: ---DEFENDANT ELK RIVER TRUSTEE INC
CLUNK, HOOSE CO., LPA
Sarah Crichigno [10083]
Attorneys for Defendant Elk River Trustee, Inc.
495 Wolf Ledges Pkwy
Akron, OH 44311
- – telephone
- - facsimile-File No-
4